News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by jdotjdot on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:16AM (#5849164)
I wish someone would post an article that actually provided a serious, levelheaded view of the ups and downs of a PhD as well as what it's actually like instead of the overly negative articles? I understand that it might not be what it seems, but it's hard to figure out what's for real and what's just somber humor for the uninitiated.
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by michaelt on Sunday June 09, 2013 @01:11PM (#5849613)
The experience of doing a PhD varies wildly - between countries, between schools, between departments, between professors, and as time passes.

Even at the same school, one person reported to me that while he was in his second year his supervisor told him he probably had enough material to pass if he wrote it all up - while another person worked long hours and reported to me that his supervisor had shouted at him for not coming in to monitor his experiments on christmas day. One person went on to a research position in the private sector and feel it set them up for a good career; another hoped to enter humanities academia, but wasn't able to find any jobs and ended up doing office admin work that barely needed an undergraduate degree.

Even for the same student, some parts of the process will be enjoyable and fascinating, other parts will be frustrating and tiresome. If you had asked me two years in I'd have told you doing a PhD is pretty great - by the end, having gone through the process of writing up, my opinion pretty inverted. I decided a career in academia wouldn't suit me at all.

If you boil the experience of doing a PhD down to the essentials of the experience, there's very little left because the experience varies so much.

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by denzil_correa on Sunday June 09, 2013 @01:40PM (#5849733)
In general, the thumb rule I would like to apply for a PhD is the function of the relationship between the graduate student (employee) and the advisor (manager). Most (not all) graduate student experiences turn bitter due to ethical and professional issues with your advisor. If I were to give any advice to a graduate student, I would write this on the top of my list.
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by jlees on Sunday June 09, 2013 @06:33PM (#5851001)
I completely agree; in my time as a PhD student and looking at my friends who did and did not finish, the only ones who made it through had a fantastic relationship with their supervisor; except for one, who was extremely driven to finish despite neglect on the part of her supervisor.
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by cwzwarich on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:06PM (#5849837)
Most? I think your sample population is suspect.
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by dnautics on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:57PM (#5850034)
most is correct. That's why sites like PhD comics and http://rezaghadiri.net/ resonate across disciplines.
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by denzil_correa on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:24PM (#5849904)
Yes, most. It follows from the same employee-manager philosophy. I don't have empirical data to prove it though. Feel free to disagree.
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by maurits on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:28AM (#5849224)
I would recommend reading "The Phd. Grind" by Philip Guo [1].

[1]: http://pgbovine.net/PhD-memoir.htm

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by pgbovine on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:36PM (#5851497)
so would I!
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by banachtarski on Sunday June 09, 2013 @01:29PM (#5849702)
The fact that you view this as an overly negative article indicates that you aren't the phd type.

I didn't opt for a phd but I sometimes wish I did. I answered C to every one of these questions.

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by onli on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:21AM (#5849196)
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by michaelochurch on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:32AM (#5849243)
There are plenty of those. Here's one: http://www.cs.unc.edu/~azuma/hitch4.html

There's also, I believe, a CMU computer science "guide to graduate school survival" out there.

I don't think that this (somewhat self-deprecating) graduate school literature is unrealistically negative. Academia is pretty awful.

Life-wise, graduate school is a pretty negative experience. If you enjoy the subject matter and have an almost obsessive need to dive into it, it's a great time in that regard (and you will be spending 60+ hours per week on your work) because you can really study without having to deal with the bullshit that professors have to fend off (committees, tenure politics, grant-writing). The rest of your life will be somewhere from mediocre (if you don't care about the academic game, already dead-set on leaving post-PhD) to awful (if you try to play for keeps); even successful and happy graduate students experience this.

The upshot of graduate school is that, except for the money and low status-- and those aren't issues for everyone-- it's actually better than being a professor. You don't have to serve on committees or sweat tenure decisions or disciplinary hearings for cheating undergraduates, and you have a 5- to 7-year period where geographic moves under adverse circumstances won't happen.

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by Xcelerate on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:22PM (#5849433)
> Life-wise, graduate school is a pretty negative experience.

I don't think grad school is like that for everyone. My undergrad had such a huge workload that I rarely had time for any kind of fun. Grad school so far is like the college that I didn't have, except I also get to work on research that's really exciting to me. I'm also kind of young for a grad student so I can hang out with undergrads just fine. It's a win-win.

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by kedean on Sunday June 09, 2013 @03:20PM (#5850108)
As a whole I think graduate school is a good thing, but moment to moment it's pretty negative, by my experience and the experience of all of my classmates. I just ended my first year of masters study, and I couldn't name one person I know within the program who didn't seriously debate dropping out numerous times over the first year. On the other hand, most of us have overall gained good experiences and knowledge, and I do not regret staying.
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by shardling on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:56PM (#5850028)
Probably worth pointing out that this particular poster has an extremely negative view of many of their life experiences! (e.g., look for their comments about working for Google.)
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by nostrademons on Sunday June 09, 2013 @05:52PM (#5850820)
Ad hominem alert!

FWIW, much as I get annoyed by Michael's constant negative comments about Google (experiences which are fairly foreign to my own experience there), they are still his experiences. Take them with a grain of salt, but take everyone's experiences from the Internet with a grain of salt.

Also FWIW, I have a number of friends who are generally shiny happy people who were basically ground down into dust in their Ph.D programs. They stayed for the whole time and not just the first year, but around year 4-6 even the most mentally stable and cheerful of them start saying things like "My life is miserable. I just want this to be over."

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by shardling on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:07PM (#5851398)
Please look at the definition of ad hominem before tossing the term around.

You also seem to have read a personal opinion into my post that simply isn't there!

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by nostrademons on Sunday June 09, 2013 @08:44PM (#5851532)
http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/ad-hominem.html

Structure of this thread:

MOC: I spent a year in graduate school. Life-wise, graduate school is a pretty negative experience.

Shardling: Probably worth pointing out that MOC has an extremely negative view of many of their life experiences.

That's exactly the form of an ad-hominem argument: Person A makes a statement, person B brings up some fact about person A that would lead them to make that statement, ergo person A's statement is invalid. The problem here is logical, not personal: just because MOC has made negative statements about other things does not mean this negative statement is without basis.

I read no such personal opinion into your post: I'm attacking your logic, not your tone.

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by shardling on Sunday June 09, 2013 @10:10PM (#5851878)
Ad hominem attacks are when you imply that someone's argument is invalid because of their background. That's what makes it a fallacy -- the validity of someone's argument is completely unrelated to their personal qualities.

http://plover.net/~bonds/adhominem.html

In contrast, when someone offers an anecdote about their experiences, or in general offers their subjective judgement, then knowing something about them is damn important! For instance, if I knew MOC was a compulsive liar, that would certainly be relevant. Likewise, if MOC was in general an optimist who was loath to ever say anything negative, that would lend extra weight to their comments on grad school.

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by michaelochurch on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:01PM (#5850294)
Actually, my year of graduate school was pretty positive, as far as things go. No complaints. I did look ahead and realize that academia was not the best deal in the world.

Also, you're a douche for bringing up irrelevancies like that.

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by shardling on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:08PM (#5850350)
I think that, if someone asks for a level-headed analysis of grad school, it is totally worth pointing out that an anecdotal response is from someone that has highly charged and divisive opinions about many things, especially institutional culture!

Also I'm pretty sure I've seen you say that you're proud of the fact that your perspective on life isn't typical -- so at least own that fact here.

Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by hyperbovine on Sunday June 09, 2013 @04:35PM (#5850464)
Really? I find that to be entirely relevant. Subtract the bias to get an unbiased estimator...
Re:Thinking of Doing a PhD? Take this simple test by wink on Sunday June 09, 2013 @02:59PM (#5850043)
It's not an article, but Matt Might writes a lot about graduate school on his blog: http://matt.might.net/articles/