Re:Lobster today is viewed as a delicacy, but was once reviled
by sjtrny on Sunday June 09, 2013 @12:49AM
(#5847627)
It's not explicitly mentioned in the Torah why shellfish are not kosher. Seems to be tradition rather than anything rational. Camels and pigs are no more toxic to eat than cows.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Lobster today is viewed as a delicacy, but was once reviled
by jrabone on Sunday June 09, 2013 @05:53AM
(#5848262)
Pigs and humans can share a wide variety of parasites, intestinal worms etc. Even now, you're advised not to cook pork rare (as opposed to, say, a beef fillet 'en-bleu').
Re:Lobster today is viewed as a delicacy, but was once reviled
by calpaterson on Sunday June 09, 2013 @05:19AM
(#5848190)
It wouldn't surprise me if pigs are not allowed because in the middle east they were (and still are, sometimes) used to clean refuse (they eat it).
Re:Lobster today is viewed as a delicacy, but was once reviled
by sk5t on Sunday June 09, 2013 @06:25PM
(#5850974)
Why on earth would one keep a pig to eat refuse when you aren't going to eat the pig? You can't milk 'em, they don't lay eggs, and they generate a lot of additional waste.
Re:Lobster today is viewed as a delicacy, but was once reviled
by geon on Sunday June 09, 2013 @09:23AM
(#5848800)
> Seems to be tradition rather than anything rational.
Whenever you eat something there is going to be a yuck-factor if it is feeding off of garbage.
I suppose that is a common factor for lobster, pigs and dogs. All of them "unclean" in Judaism.