Re:Why a top terrorism analyst thinks US government surveill...
by AnthonyMouse on Saturday June 08, 2013 @04:33PM
(#5846218)
The answer to this is that the bad guys are doing it too. If Facebook is based in the US, China and Iran will eventually break into it and compromise national security. If Facebook was based in Germany, China and Iran (and the NSA) would eventually break into it and compromise national security. It doesn't really change anything.
However, if Facebook was a distributed system, such that no one could compromise it in its entirety at a central location, it would help keep the bad guys out. Which in this context is more important, because we have a lot more spies, undercover law enforcement officers, military and commercial secrets etc. that we need to protect than we have terrorists we can't catch through other means. Which, for exactly that reason, is the way things would go if they move away from centralized US servers in response to spying fears. There is a reason the Navy sponsored Tor.
However, if Facebook was a distributed system, such that no one could compromise it in its entirety at a central location, it would help keep the bad guys out. Which in this context is more important, because we have a lot more spies, undercover law enforcement officers, military and commercial secrets etc. that we need to protect than we have terrorists we can't catch through other means. Which, for exactly that reason, is the way things would go if they move away from centralized US servers in response to spying fears. There is a reason the Navy sponsored Tor.