So given that, I think it's worthwhile to actually test their assertion (I.e. not rush to judgment) rather than patting ourselves on the back with the logical fallacies of:
* "Well, the reports about Facebook and Google must be true because it comes from a group that is itself evil and who I would normally not believe" (the enemy of my enemy is my friend)
* "Well, what else would you expect an obviously evil entity to say after being accused of evil acts?" (circular reasoning).
Again, it's not because Google and Facebook are poor disenfranchised groups that must be sympathized with, but because it feels a little dishonest to subject them to the same kind of inescapable logical trap that our government has used to go after and prosecute suspected enemies of the state
Just out of curiosity...can you really not imagine a less transparent corporation than either Google or Facebook?
And I don't think it's an either-or situation: either it's the truth and they deny, or it's false and they deny. There's a third option: it's true, and they remain silent.
If you can find a more transparent company when it comes to government data requests I would love to know about that company.
And no shit Facebook and Google are in damage control mode. They'd be in damage control mode regardless of if they are guilty or innocent, this is a huge PR disaster for both of them and nobody seems to give a shit what the facts are - this went from a few bad power point slides to national panic overnight.
> Now, these accounts are being updated in real-time. So Facebook somehow creates a mirror of the slice of stuff that only the NSA can access. The selected/court-ordered accounts are updated in real-time on both the Facebook server and the mirrored server.
Does this "slice" contain material and accounts gathered only after the legal review that Facebook claims that it performs?
If so, then this story gels with what the NYT reported, that some organizations have built a secure framework to expedite the transmission of requested data...which makes sense, depending on the nature of the investigation...that is...if the NSA has requested data on a suspect on an ongoing case...then they'd probably want that datastore to be updated...in the same way that they want wiretaps to stay on the wire during the investigation.
Note: this is not to say that such surveillance is justified, but that this program makes sense with what Facebook and Google said yesterday and with the reports by the WaPo and the Guardian. Whether this is substantially worse than the other apparatuses we have in place, such as NSL, is also up for debate.