Re:Cowards
by natrius on Saturday June 08, 2013 @05:14AM
(#5844395)
I don't think we have enough information to come to that conclusion. Plain old FISA orders are lawful and constitutional. There's no good reason to disclose them, but there is a good reason to push for a limited term on their secrecy. As described, PRISM is far from a plain old FISA order. It sounds like they're collecting data broadly. If that's the case, that's worth leaking. Someone thought so.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Also consider this. They have a 51% confidence that the target is foreigner.
In the case of gmail, "please send me a random 10 users' info, data, and emails" gives you over a 70% chance that any given one in that sample is a foreigner. With Facebook it is closer to 85%.
So think about that. It means the filters could deliberately overinclude Americans and still meet their standards.
"Plain old FISA orders are lawful and constitutional."
Maybe that is currently true; jailing Japanese Americans also passed court muster. Secret orders from a secret court doesn't square with the ideals of America I was taught in civics class.