News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Insane Law That Lets Authorities Read Any Email Over ... by rayiner on Saturday June 08, 2013 @03:29AM (#5844229)
> I enjoy how your response to Spooner's criticism of the Constitution is to declare that the Constitution permits these invasive acts

I declare it because it's true, at least as the law stands right now. The Constitution doesn't just say whatever you want it to say. The fact that the actions are "invasive" doesn't mean they're unconstitutional.

Did you know that a lawyer in a civil litigation can use the power of the courts, through a subpoena, to obtain nearly any information or force nearly anyone to testify as long as it's relevant to a litigation? And that subpoena is enforced through the threat of contempt of court? This is incredibly invasive, yet it's a basic feature of our court system. From an 1802 Evidence textbook: "It is the undoubted legal constitutional right of every subject of the realm who has a cause depending to call upon a fellow subject to testify what he may know of the matters in issue and every man is bound to make the discovery unless specially exempted and protected by law."

The balance that has been struck in our system is not one where the protection of "privacy" trumps all other concerns. Indeed, the scale is heavily tilted the other way: the government, especially pursuant to a court order, has broad powers to seek out information subject to specific protections (4th, 5th amendment).

Re:The Insane Law That Lets Authorities Read Any Email Over ... by ataggart on Saturday June 08, 2013 @10:55AM (#5845020)
>The fact that the actions are "invasive" doesn't mean they're unconstitutional.

Perhaps, though that only reinforces Spooner's point. Given the repeated attempts to frame this as only an issue of explicit prohibition, I think that perhaps you're trying to counter an argument I'm not actually making.

Anyone who tries to make a claim of "unconstitutionality" -- or argue against someone making a claim of "constitutionality" -- is wasting their time. The Constitution means precisely whatever the people can be convinced it means, and that in turn is decided largely by a handful of individuals in power. If something as explicit as the Seventh Amendment's "twenty dollars" clause can be argued away, then anything can.

Sometimes, as is (slightly, temporarily) the case now, the people may find an act of the state egregiously wrong, and look for protection in the Constitution. Thankfully we have people like you to remind them that they are incorrect. From this the value of the Constitution is revealed: the imprimatur of legitimacy it provides to those in power when they commit otherwise illegitimate acts.

Re:The Insane Law That Lets Authorities Read Any Email Over ... by dragonwriter on Saturday June 08, 2013 @11:08AM (#5845059)
> Anyone who tries to make a claim of "unconstitutionality" -- or argue against someone making a claim of "constitutionality" -- is wasting their time. The Constitution means precisely whatever the people can be convinced it means

Seems to be a very good reason why persuasion based around "constitutionality" is not a waste of time.

> and that in turn is decided largely by a handful of individuals in power.

Well, no, its decided by what the people accept, which depends pretty much entirely on the arguments they are exposed to. Certain individuals in power in government and the media have some advantages in terms of inherent trust with some segment of the population on the issue, or just a bigger microphone, but those can be overcome. Even in states where the means of mass communication have been far more tightly controlled than they are in the US, "what the people can be convinced of" has often conflicted with what those in power want; preaching defeatism of the kind you are here is precisely the thing that serves to reinforce the power of the elites, which mostly comes from other people giving up.

Re:The Insane Law That Lets Authorities Read Any Email Over ... by ataggart on Saturday June 08, 2013 @12:09PM (#5845287)
>Seems to be a very good reason why persuasion based around "constitutionality" is not a waste of time.

Perhaps, but it's not a very good reason to engage in an argument with someone making positive claims about "constitutionality" (e.g., rayiner).

Personally, I'm disinclined to participate in a lie merely in the hopes of yielding a favorable outcome, particularly when doing so cedes the fundamental point of my position. I am content to simply note the lie.