News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yours in distress, Alan by sp332 on Saturday June 08, 2013 @12:07AM (#5843749)
OK, pretty much with you so far. Now I'm trying to show that the choice of whom to have sex with is not at all the same thing as the non-choice of whom to be attracted to. Even gay people have the choice not to have sex with people of the same gender, exactly the same way straight people have the choice not to have sex with people of the opposite gender.
Re:Yours in distress, Alan by tommorris on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:41AM (#5843975)
True but obvious. What interesting implications do you think this has for the argument around either sexual orientation or discrimination? Because I can't really see one.

Nutters who leave nail bombs in gay bars are still going to do so regardless of whether I choose to have sex or not. If I have a non-sexual romantic relationship with someone, and we walk through the park holding hands, I still have to worry about some crazy person coming along and being a shitbag about it. If I disclose my sexual orientation, I still have to worry about discrimination in the workplace and housing provision and so on. The issues don't go away just because one is not actively having sex.

Re:Yours in distress, Alan by jules on Saturday June 08, 2013 @04:53AM (#5844366)
Of course? Gay or straight is who you're attracted to, not who you have sex with. And this is not at all what you were saying further up in the tread? You were talking about attraction, not who you have sex with. I think everybody pretty much agrees that who you have sex with is a choice (except for the issue of whether free will exists at all). So far the evidence points to that being gay or straight, that is, who you're attracted to, is at least for the most part not a choice.
Re:Yours in distress, Alan by sp332 on Saturday June 08, 2013 @09:03AM (#5844774)
I agree there have been a lot of topics in this thread :) But my point way back up at the top is just this: If being gay is defined by who you're attracted to, and "who you're attracted to" can change, then "being gay" is probably not something hardwired into you before you are born. Correlate, sure. Not something you can consciously control, sure. But I really think it's something that must be taken on a moment-by-moment basis, not a lifetime-by-lifetime basis.