News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by danso on Friday June 07, 2013 @06:04PM (#5842297)
OK, this sounds pedantic, but "Convicted for Longer"* is not accurate...you're not convicted for a period of time, you're convicted and then sentenced to a period of jail time, or probation.

And of course, as we all know from the Aaron Swartz coverage, "could serve for as long as..." is different than "actually serve a sentence of [xy] ears".

But the most relevant quibble is this: a father who beats these rapists with his fists would also face a longer sentence than these accused rapists (who, according to the OP, faced 1-2 years)...because these convicted offenders were juveniles.

And as much as we want to celebrate extra-judicial vengenance upon convicts, juvenile or not, I think we should be aware that there may be unpleasant consequences when our justice/political system looks the other way upon unlawful actions in which "the ends justified the means".

...because, I mean, isn't that at the core of the NSA controversy that is currently raging in the the other 20 HN threads?

* edit: the original title for this submission was "Hacker...Could Be Convicted for Longer..."

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by sliverstorm on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:20PM (#5843397)
I think we should be aware that there may be unpleasant consequences...

Or as I like to put it, something about having your cake and eating it. We can't demand the administration turn a blind eye here, and rage at that same administration when they turn a blind eye there.

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by Houshalter on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:20AM (#5843930)
No one is asking to turn a blind eye, but a ten year sentence is absurd. If they actually get it that is.
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by 6d0debc071 on Saturday June 08, 2013 @09:53AM (#5844860)
========QUOTE==========

> But the most relevant quibble is this: a father who beats these rapists with his fists would also face a longer sentence than these accused rapists (who, according to the OP, faced 1-2 years)...because these convicted offenders were juveniles.* *

=======================

These offenders were teenagers. They are not five years old, they know - at least in general terms - what's right and wrong, and they know what will hurt someone. And they did it anyway.

Charging someone as a juvenile ought to be for kiddy-screwup fist fights and stupid kid mistakes, so that some momentary lack of judgement doesn't screw someone's life up, not for raping someone - that's not a momentary mistake.

========QUOTE==========

And as much as we want to celebrate extra-judicial vengenance upon convicts, juvenile or not, I think we should be aware that there may be unpleasant consequences when our justice/political system looks the other way upon unlawful actions in which "the ends justified the means".

...because, I mean, isn't that at the core of the NSA controversy that is currently raging in the the other 20 HN threads?

=======================

Not from my point of view, no. The law is going to be selectively enforced - there's nothing you can do about it. And the law is so ridiculously messed up that total enforcement isn't even something desirable. The average person commits, I believe it's 3, felonies a day. The US gov can't even count all the laws anymore. We're all guilty.

That's why you need a system that lets people adjust the application of law for common decency. That's why you need a jury of your peers with the ability to refuse to convict. (Granted, a legal theory that seems relatively unknown these days.)

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by tomjen3 on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:51AM (#5844000)
Not only is it pedantic, you are a terrible human for wanting to lock a father who beats up a rapist for longer than the rapist.

These men were old enough to rape, they should be old enough to do the time and if your excuse was that they were juveniles, then just remember that they could (and should have been) charged as adults. Alas the bastards weren't, but that is prosecutal misconduct, not justice.

Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by anigbrowl on Saturday June 08, 2013 @02:46AM (#5844127)
People like you are the reason I would waive my right to a jury trial. You are so caught up in your own bias that it causes you to literally see things that aren't there, like your accusation that danso 'want[s] to lock a father who beats up a rapist for longer than the rapist.'
Re:Hacker Who Helped Expose Steubenville Could Get More Pris... by winter_blue on Saturday June 08, 2013 @04:21AM (#5844320)
I don't think danso was necessarily agreeing with that sentiment — he was just pointing out that the current reality of the justice system would result in such sentencing.