I have a bunch of problems with IPv6:
* IPv6 doesn't solve the multicast problem; multicast was attempted in an IP context and failed because when you try to express something as complex as group message delivery on IP, you needlessly complicate things, and because multicast on IP simply doesn't scale, because it conceptually requires core routers to maintain routing state for individual pieces of content.
* The topology of IPv6 is controlled by giant telecoms; also, some of what you are and aren't allowed to do with the connectivity you buy is controlled by telecoms. I don't have a moral problem with this, but it's a needless coupling between Internet and telephony businesses.
* IPv6 doesn't move us from our current state of "by default I don't have direct peer level connectivity with hosts", because in the IPv6 world, everyone will still be hiding behind firewalls, because for 2 decades the crappy software we had hanging out on TCP and UDP ports turned out to be too unsafe to expose. Overlays that would provide direct connectivity --- in the same sense as I can IM you on AIM or Gtalk right now --- would be starting fresh and would provide default direct connectivity to everyone. Anyone who's ever had to punch a hole through a firewall to allow inbound connectivity understands this.
* IPv6 is tremendously expensive to deploy: http://cr.yp.to/djbdns/ipv6mess.html --- forget the routers, we have so much software that has to get forklifted out to accomodate addresses that don't act like scalar integers.
If you want to throw out TCP/IP, I hope you have specific dramatic improvements for its replacement in mind.