But neither thread is one of substance, only complaints and a vague "we need a general overlay network". Not one word about what it should look like. How it should work. Nothing.
If you want to argue about an idea, articulate one.
Edit: I see in the second thread you actually did say something about a directory service, so I guess that is one word. But as far as I can tell, you just described yet-another-DNS-replacement. If I were generous, maybe I would call it an Active Directory competitor.
Boo! You continue to say. New ideas bad! How dare you, of all people, assault the old ideas!
Edit: Ah, you've edited it to clarify. You're just going to be your usual self. How disappointing. Broadly speaking, you're an interesting, intelligent person I would love to know better and to learn from. But you can't stop yourself from being the get-off-my-lawn guy.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5587264
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3408523
All you've said so far is "Boo! New ideas bad!"