Re:How likely is the NSA PRISM program to catch a terrorist?
by mercurial on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:38PM
(#5840325)
That's the point. Torture can cause collateral damage. These people were not guilty of what they were accused of. But at the same time, you can find out a number of examples of torture giving results.
Re:How likely is the NSA PRISM program to catch a terrorist?
by flyinRyan on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:40PM
(#5840338)
But again, for all the examples you can name of "giving results" how many can you prove gave accurate results? And if you can prove the torture produced accurate results that means you have a reliable outside verification mechanism, at which point the question becomes: why didn't you just use that mechanism instead of torture?
Re:How likely is the NSA PRISM program to catch a terrorist?
by mercurial on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:43AM
(#5843980)
Following the arrest, torture (often followed by extra-judicial executions) of numerous FLN members in Algiers and civilian collaborators, the FLN organization in the area was destroyed, and its bombing campaign ended.
Getting information, I'd say not very effective. The issue is, what if the person really doesn't know? How do you tell the difference? You listed some examples, but how did you confirm that this information was true and not just bullshit these people were saying to make the torture stop? In the end, weren't the "loyalists" just killed anyway? Maybe they weren't actually loyal so they were simply killed and logged as loyalists. Since the main "evidence" is testimony under extreme duress there's no way to know for sure.