Re:Intelligence Chief Calls Leaks on U.S. Data Collection ‘R...
by sologoub on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:06PM
(#5840111)
The "legal" part is what's probably the most important question. Is it really legal? Or is it legal, so long as it has not been disclosed and made illegal by general public outcry?
Sounds too much like "not caught, not a criminal" philosophy.
Re:Intelligence Chief Calls Leaks on U.S. Data Collection ‘R...
by lawnchair_larry on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:51PM
(#5840420)
Who cares if it's legal? They just change the laws when the laws get in the way. It is certainly unjust however.
Re:Intelligence Chief Calls Leaks on U.S. Data Collection ‘R...
by pfortuny on Friday June 07, 2013 @03:10PM
(#5840988)
This is what legal positivism ends up turning into: anything is legal as long as there is a "law" allowing it. The fact that said law may be -f.e.- unconstitutional has nothing to do with the 'legality' of the act. Only when -if- a superior entity (the SCOTUS in this case) deems the 'law' unconstitutional does the act become 'illegal.'
So always win-win for the NSA.
Re:Intelligence Chief Calls Leaks on U.S. Data Collection ‘R...
by darkmethod on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:29PM
(#5840270)
I'm starting to question if morality and legality are considered the same by those in power? Honest question, although off topic and a bit esoteric.
Said without an apparent hint of irony.
In time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell