News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by w_t_payne on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:08AM (#5838637)
Sorry, but you cannot and should not fight. The asymmetry in power is too great. The last thing you want to do is find yourself labelled as a "troublemaker" or (worse) as an "enemy". The state has an almost unlimited capacity to ruin the lives of those whom it targets. The best, safest thing for us all is to keep quiet, stay out of politics, and learn to think carefully about what we say or do before we say or do it. If you start to act aggressively, then you run the risk of putting yourself (and the entire community) in danger. I repeat again (for emphasis): Challenging the agencies is a sure-fire way to get yourself and those around you into a whole world of trouble. Do not do it. Do not even think about doing it:- just keep your head down and keep quiet - for all our sakes.
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by PostOnce on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:20AM (#5838680)
The only possible outcome of such behavior is a worsening situation. How is that defensible?

Nothing risked, nothing gained.

Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by esalazar on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:51AM (#5838868)
Agreed. The only way for change is to thrash and thrash hard.
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by jf22 on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:35AM (#5839487)
That sounds very violent...
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by w_t_payne on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:39AM (#5839137)
They may be bought, but they cannot be fought -- taking risks is one thing, but you need to weigh the risks and the rewards: this fight is all downside.
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by antoinevg on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:07AM (#5839313)
I kept looking for the <sarcasm> tag… and well mate… all I can say is I'm deeply grateful not everyone felt the same as you in South Africa during the 80's.
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by w_t_payne on Saturday June 08, 2013 @05:30AM (#5844422)
Yeah, well, sometimes you have to bury the <sarcasm> tag a bit if you want to goad people into responding...
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by kunai on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:02AM (#5838924)
IF that's the risk it takes, so be it. Safety be damned; this is the welfare of my children's, your children's, and their children's, future.

And our future too. We're going to be here quite a while.

Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by w_t_payne on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:37AM (#5839124)
You are a fool and an idiot if you think that you can fight the agencies (and by extension the state) and win. 90% of winning is choosing your battles wisely - do not choose this one. You. Will. End. Up. Hurt.
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by jaworrom on Friday June 07, 2013 @12:04PM (#5839694)
Last I checked, there is exponentially more citizens than government officials. Most military sides with the people. A few cowards would side with the government, but most would support their fellow citizens... the government isn't all that mighty when you consider this...

I dearly hope such a standoff never has to occur, as I think there are better ways to solve these issues we have with our bloated government.

Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by w_t_payne on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:07PM (#5840123)
Well, the numerical advantage is not always as dramatic as you presuppose: (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stasi). Also, your assumption that the entire remainder of the populace is "on side" is possibly a little optimistic. All the state has to do is ensure sufficient apathy to whittle those odds down to something that (with it's organizational, technological and financial advantage) is comfortably one-sided (to the advantage of the state).
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by kunai on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:51AM (#5839604)
First of all, ad hominem never helped anyone.

Second, I don't for a second expect to win. The point is not to win at all, it's to start something. I'm not the only one who believes so; there are plenty others who believe the same and are willing to risk imprisonment, scorn, or injury to advance rights (e.g. Aaron Swartz. If you wish to disagree you may).

We are perhaps a little bit more free than we were in the '60s, but for the last 70 years, we have been limited by secret, corrupt government and a legislature that really sucks.

Third, you say I should choose my battles wisely, yet in your original post you suggested I do nothing at all. How is that choosing a battle at all? I'm preaching peaceful protest, and you imply that we should sit by while everything falls to pieces. Do you want your kids to grow up in a world that is ruled, not led?

Call me a conspirast, but it will be true if these conditions continue.

Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by w_t_payne on Friday June 07, 2013 @12:26PM (#5839834)
True, to a rational mind, the insult and slander that I have committed against you is a distraction from the debate and the pursuit of truth ... but since when did we become rational creatures? The value of truth was always an illusion to which we paid but lip-service; the deeper nature of reality is that our world; our society is built on nothing more than lies and delusion. Say something often enough and it becomes true through repetition and memory. Say it vehemently enough and you gain followers, mouthpieces for your message.

Rationality and critical thinking are myths. For all practical purposes they do not exist. So, I say it again. Technology is a lever. Over time, it amplifies pre-existing power relationships. Good becomes great, bad becomes evil. Which is which? We cannot tell. Both are banal; grey; undifferentiated. Where subservient relationships exist, they become entrenched; the vulnerable, exposed.

In terms of dynamics, basins of stability become inverted; hills pushing the world-state towards extrema, old arrangements; unbalanced.

Information is power; control the information, control the ideas, control the people. I wish it were not so. I wish that this fatalistic voice; this persona of doom; an expression of my darkest fears ... I wish that it were not so readily adopted. I wish that it were more clearly "playing the fool" ... but my wishes are confounded by a great and dreadful uncertainty ... I wish that my cry could be: "Hail the brave", but my doubts cloud my mind...

so I sink to playing petty, trivialising language-games, because I no longer know what matters and what does not ...

Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by joonix on Friday June 07, 2013 @12:13PM (#5839759)
The people who want to "start something" generally have nothing to lose. The average American in the suburbs with a family has plenty to lose. Their children, their spouse, their job/income and providing, and safety, are far more of a concern to them than their phone records being spied on by the government in the name of counter terrorism. People riot and rebel when they are starving, not when their stomaches are full.
Re:Ask HN: The government has been exposed now what? by w_t_payne on Monday June 10, 2013 @04:56AM (#5853152)
Unfortunately, this is the world that we live in: https://mailman.stanford.edu/pipermail/liberationtech/2013-J...