News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How likely is the NSA PRISM program to catch a terrorist? by mtgx on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:14AM (#5837830)
I think what his data shows is that out of 10,000 terrorists, it might help catch one.

Remember they've been doing this for more than a decade, and it still didn't help them with the Boston bombers. They even had the guy in custody before. Still didn't help. The abuse of surveillance power is not effective, even if it was legal/constitutional.

Re:How likely is the NSA PRISM program to catch a terrorist? by jlgreco on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:57AM (#5837941)
No, his calculation shows P(baddy|flag)=1/10,000. In other words, given that the system flags somebody, there is only a 1/10,000 chance that this person was correctly flagged.

This is given the absurdly high P(flag|baddy) of .99 (a terrorist raises a flag 99% of the time... good luck with that.) and a P(flag|innocent person) of .01 (meaning that in the US an absolutely staggering 3.19 million people would be wrongfully flagged by this system). Then there is P(baddy)=1/1,000,000, which implies that we believe there are 300+ terrorists currently in the US that desperately need to be caught. What the hell have those 300+ terrorists been doing in the past few years? Wishing they could only find guns the the great US of A? 1/10,000,000 is a far more reasonable number, though even 1/100,000,000 is probably being generous.

1/10,000 is absolutely abysmal. When you start punching in more realistic numbers though the result becomes much worse and you rapidly approach a situation where you would have more luck flagging random US citizens as uncaught criminals than you will with using this system to identify terrorists. If you permit those sort of absurd odds, then even hiring "forensic psychics" to investigate murders in small towns starts to make sense...

This sort of screening flat out does not work for something as rare as terrorists. It only works when you start bumping your P(baddy) way up (dropping P(flag|innocent person) is not practical, and raising P(flag|baddy) to even more absurdly high levels only gets you marginal improvements). Replace 'terrorist' with 'person of interest to the DEA' or 'tax cheat' and suddenly this sort of screening starts to look a hell of a lot more practical.... hmm....

Re:How likely is the NSA PRISM program to catch a terrorist? by dwild on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:49AM (#5838836)
Wait, media were talking about Prism before? You have no idea the effect they had on terrorism. We can't tell with the information we have currently. We don't even know which information is true. Maybe they saved ton of terrorist attack, maybe they got multiple criminal or killers with that, but we won't know because they never said it was with the help of Prism.

All we know is that this project cost 20 millions, they had access to informations from a dozen companies, which is easily multiples hundred terabytes, probably even petabytes. I doubt 20 millions is enough to do anything useful with these informations. However can we even trust theses slides?...

Re:How likely is the NSA PRISM program to catch a terrorist? by flyinRyan on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:46PM (#5840374)
Why on earth would you assume it's working? This is immoral and wrong, it's up to the government to show that it's buying us something (but I'd be against it even then). If they don't show that we should assume it hasn't stopped even one crime.