News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by chez17 on Thursday June 06, 2013 @10:14AM (#5832520)
There is nothing more intellectually childish than saying "x isn't working in this case, therefore x never works and should be totally abandoned." I agree 100% that 99% of people don't care about politics enough and vote blindly. Look at the turn out rate for primaries and years where people aren't voting for president. Libertarians like you are all talk. There plenty of places in this world with no government but you would never go there because they are 3rd world shit holes. Ask yourself, "why aren't there any first world countries that are prosperous that have libertarian governments?" You love government. You love roads, infrastructure, safe food, safe cars, you take things like electricity, water, and internet for granted, you bathe in government funded projects that have made your life better in every way. The answer isn't no government, it's better government. In some areas that means drastically reducing it's power and I think even the left most progressive could agree with the right most libertarian on many things. However it's just childish to say "no government". It's been tried before in the past, and it's being tried now, it never works. We do better when we work together.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Thursday June 06, 2013 @10:59AM (#5832795)
No government? Who said that? Where?

We need a simple and limited government that remains out of our lives in nearly every imaginable way. Every human being on this planet is born free. We created these monstrous governmental systems that, effectively, enslave us in one way or another.

I can't go for a swim in my local lake. My government will not allow it. I can easily swim 1500 meters or more. Swim every day. Yet, if I so much as stick my FOOT in the lake they'll warn me that this is not allowed.

Los Angeles County has a "no water contact" policy. I've had a lifeguard in a power boat rush over to me while walking with my children along the shore in six inches of water to tell us we could not get our feet wet. If I did try to go for a swim I could be arrested and fined. Really? Yes, really. And this is just one example.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by d23 on Thursday June 06, 2013 @11:05AM (#5832828)
> No government? Who said that? Where? We need a simple and limited government.

No, no, no. Stop backpedaling. You said this before:

> Ultra limited government.

That's pretty close to "no" government, so his points still stand. The problem isn't government in general, any more than it is people in general. It's things that are broken or aren't working well.

It can just as easily be said about the private sector. Yesterday my UPS person claimed he tried to deliver a package but I didn't answer the door. Bullshit. I was home the entire time and he never came.

Did I go on a rant about the evils of the private sector and how everything needs to be socialized? No. I recognized that for every annoying experience I have with a private corporation I have 3 other good ones that make my life better.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Thursday June 06, 2013 @11:30AM (#5833020)
No, ultra-limited government means a government with significantly reduced power, reach and size with respect to what we have today. It does not mean "no government". Considering how massive and all encompassing our governments are now, even after severely reducing it at all levels we'd still have quite a few people running our cities, states and country.

You can twist it any way you want but nobody is calling for no government, that would be insane.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by jbooth on Thursday June 06, 2013 @12:35PM (#5833447)
It means damn near nothing, getting to ideologically have your cake and eat it too.

Reform is hard and involves details. Whining about "too much government" doesn't require any details at all. It's like Paul Ryan's budget plan that has huge line items of savings under, and I'm not making this up, "spending cuts" and "tax reform", with no further specifics. Hey, who could be against that? There's nothing negative about it, just some huge savings!

You want less government? Great. Get a marker and about 5 million pages in your printer and start printing out the US budget to mark it up for your suggestions. Because there isn't a single whole department you could cut without seriously screwing up society, you have to get into the weeds.

Want to cut this NSA program? Great, I agree with you. We do need the NSA around in some form with a smaller mandate, though.

Want to eliminate the FCC? You probably haven't thought about why it's illegal for me to buy a 1,000MW transmitter and drown out WNBC with Rick Astley on repeat.

Want to eliminate entitlements? You need a backup plan that won't have people dying in the streets, and actually spends less money. Looping in private contractors to spend more money or provide less benefits is not smaller government.

All 3 of these scenarios (and I could keep going) involve smarter government. Sure, saving money means "less" in some senses but the point is being smarter, not just randomly being upset at the aggregate size of things that you support in isolation.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by VikingCoder on Thursday June 06, 2013 @12:17PM (#5833331)
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by wolfpackk on Thursday June 06, 2013 @11:14AM (#5832885)
hop on the government paved roads to drive to a lake that you couldn't get arrested for trespassing on because the government has preserved it this long, then hop on the darpa/dod funded internet to complain that you can't go fucking swimming is the epitome of irony. Go fuck yourself.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Thursday June 06, 2013 @11:33AM (#5833037)
It is better to remain silent and be thought...

May I suggest that getting an education might do wonders for your life? Just a thought.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by wolfpackk on Thursday June 06, 2013 @11:47AM (#5833119)
resorting to ad hominems rather than reason, pretty typical for the moronic libertarian technophiles that seem to be all over hn.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Thursday June 06, 2013 @11:54AM (#5833169)
Really? And "go fuck yourself" is "reason" how?

I am merely a mirror for the direction you chose to take. If you want to discuss the topic with civility I am all for it so long as you don't ask me to do things with my body I am quite literally biologically incapable of doing.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by wolfpackk on Thursday June 06, 2013 @12:43PM (#5833497)
Merely reflecting the tone you've taken throughout this post. Then to use the passive-aggressive "May I suggest getting an education" bit is incredibly condescending, especially given that your position of less-government is universally better, after being scrubbed of the sensationalist rhetoric you are spewing, has literally 0 empirical evidence behind it. There is a reason Austrian economics is not taken seriously.

I especially like that fact that you asked less than 1.5 years ago about the best online CS program, then have the audacity to tell someone to get an education. You probably do not know jack shit about econ or cs.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Thursday June 06, 2013 @07:36PM (#5836026)
Wrong on so many points.

Feel free to contact me privately with your real name and LinkedIn profile link. My email address is in my profile. I'll send you my LinkedIn URL and you can figure out just what kind of a moron I am.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Thursday June 06, 2013 @07:29PM (#5835974)
You are a piece of work, aren't you?

Interesting that you went back and researched my comment history. So, your assumption was that I am a kid looking for a CS degree? Now, that's really funny! Thanks.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by wolfpackk on Thursday June 06, 2013 @09:42PM (#5836626)
I just found it ironic that you tell someone to get educated, when you don't have a degree, which is pretty obvious given your inability to ignore rhetoric and respond to the merits of an argument. U mad
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:33AM (#5839471)
I wish HN had a way to kill-off these kinds of exchanges.

When someone opens a new comment branch with "Go fuck yourself" nothing good can follow. In retrospect I probably should have completely ignored this. I, in a very real sense, became part of the problem by providing a stage of sorts. I am sorry for that.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Thursday June 06, 2013 @07:32PM (#5836001)
You know, maybe you out to calm down and think before you type.

If it makes you happy, yes you are right, I don't know jack shit about economics or cs. There, you won.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by cakebread on Thursday June 06, 2013 @12:33PM (#5833429)
Getting a chubby at any chance to say "ad hominem" is also typical HN.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by wolfpackk on Thursday June 06, 2013 @01:06PM (#5833634)
Given that the poster robomartin is less than 1.5 years away from asking what the best (undergrad) online CS degree is, I felt it was particularly apt in this case.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by talmand on Thursday June 06, 2013 @10:27AM (#5832598)
He didn't say nor have I ever heard a libertarian claim they wanted no government. I believe that's a different ideology.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by VikingCoder on Thursday June 06, 2013 @11:01AM (#5832804)
He said, "Ultra limited government."

Does ultra-limited government include government-provided roads, infrastructure, safe food, safe cars, electricity, water, internet?

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by jaekwon on Thursday June 06, 2013 @12:24PM (#5833369)
No reason it couldn't. It's not the size of a government that determines its efficacy, esp with the right kind of private-sector support.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by VikingCoder on Thursday June 06, 2013 @01:09PM (#5833657)
Then it's a MEANINGLESS PHRASE.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by talmand on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:15AM (#5838992)
Just because you don't like it or don't agree doesn't make it meaningless.

It means exactly what it says. There is nothing to show that an ultra-limited government cannot perform the needed tasks for society such as you provide. But I say there's a big difference between a government that provides what's needed for society and the monstrosity that's currently in place in Washington D.C.

When I say something along the lines of ultra-limited I mean I want most of the political decisions that affect my life to be decided on the local or state level before it becomes a federal issue. That's exactly how the US was designed, but that's not the way it is being run now. The federal government actually has a list of things it is to do, by the way Post Offices and Roads are covered so I have no problem with that, but a great deal of what it does goes way beyond that list.

My definition of a ultra-limited federal government? Simple. It's what the Constitution says it is.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by VikingCoder on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:51AM (#5839603)
> Simple. It's what the Constitution says it is.

Every single thing the government does today has been because of laws written by Congress, signed and enacted by the head of the Executive, and upheld by the Judiciary.

How can you even BEGIN to make the claim that it's unconstitutional?

That's the DEFINITION of Constitutional.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by dragonwriter on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:57AM (#5839649)
> Every single thing the government does today has been because of laws written by Congress, signed and enacted by the head of the Executive, and upheld by the Judiciary.

Incorrect. Many of things the government does today are done either within or outside of specific purported statutory authority (in the latter case, if there is a theoretical justification, it relates to inherent powers of particular offices that do not require legislation to activate) outside of the scope of theories of justification that have been challenged in the courts. Its also quite likely that at least some things government does today are things that have been rejected by the courts in the past -- and which would be again if they were challenged again (certainly, it stretches credibility to claim that, despite all the past missteps, many of which involved repeats of the same violation, the government has just recently become perfectly compliant.)

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by VikingCoder on Friday June 07, 2013 @12:57PM (#5840037)
You imply that HUGE SWATHS of what the Federal Government are unconstitutional, and that's complete bunk.

If you disagree, figure out a way to get a court case, or write to your representatives or try to become one. That's how it works.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by dragonwriter on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:05PM (#5840102)
> You imply that HUGE SWATHS of what the Federal Government are unconstitutional

I'm not sure on what basis you infer that thing about HUGE SWATHS from what I said.

> and that's complete bunk.

While, contrary to your claim, I didn't say (or imply) that it was true, I also don't see the evidence that it is "complete bunk". Please present it.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by VikingCoder on Friday June 07, 2013 @01:52PM (#5840428)
Seriously? You're going to make me play this game?

"most of the political decisions that affect my life to be decided on the local or state level before it becomes a federal issue. That's exactly how the US was designed, but that's not the way it is being run now"

MOST... federal... the way it is being run now.

MOST means more than 50%.

And that's complete bunk: it is not the case that 50% of the political decisions made by the federal government that affect your life are unconstitutional.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by dragonwriter on Friday June 07, 2013 @02:08PM (#5840550)
> Seriously? You're going to make me play this game?

I'm not making you do anything. If I could, I'd make you read posts more carefully (including the attribution line) before responding to them, though.

> "most of the political decisions that affect my life to be decided on the local or state level before it becomes a federal issue. That's exactly how the US was designed, but that's not the way it is being run now"

That quote is neither from my post [1] that you responded to [2] with the claim that "You imply that HUGE SWATHS of what the Federal Government are unconstitutional", nor from any other post of mine, in this thread, nor, for that matter, from anywhere else, ever. It's from someone else entirely. [3]

And it doesn't say that most things that government is doing are unconstitutional (as you claim now), or even that "HUGE SWATHS" are not (as you claimed before), it says that if the government was strictly doing only what was Constitutional, then most issues would be decided at the local or state level, and that is not what is happening now. So, even if it wasn't for the fact that it was irrelevant to the post it was offered in response to, and misattributed to the wrong person, your characterization would still be wrong.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5839649 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5840037 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5838992

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by nitrogen on Thursday June 06, 2013 @02:01PM (#5834061)
Maybe "ultra-" in this case was used to indicate that the limits would be strict, not that they would be extremely small.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by VikingCoder on Thursday June 06, 2013 @02:17PM (#5834181)
Maybe "ultra-" is a meaningless phrase that makes people feel good, but conveys zero information content, and so it's not worthy of debate.
Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by d23 on Thursday June 06, 2013 @11:01AM (#5832802)
> Ultra limited government.

Pretty damn close.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by robomartin on Thursday June 06, 2013 @12:13PM (#5833296)
Nope. A rough count shows that over twenty million people work directly for our govenments from local to federal.

http://www2.census.gov/govs/apes/11fedfun.pdf

http://www2.census.gov/govs/apes/11stlus.txt

If we reduced government by 90% by reduction, automation, privatization and outright agency elimination you'd still have two million people in government.

"Ultra-limited" does not mean "no government".

I think 50% to 75% could be a good range. So you'd still have somewhere between five and ten million people in government.

Also, "ultra limited" refers more to what they are allowed to do rather than how many.

Re:Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans by Dirlewanger on Thursday June 06, 2013 @10:52AM (#5832753)
Nice job busting out a rant that no one provoked.