Re:Wikipedia’s Emergency
by derleth on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @09:08PM
(#5829764)
Deletionism is the only reason Wikipedia remains using. Without deletions, it would have sunk into the world of spam-trap and personal blog platform long ago.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Delete the garbage, but leave the trivial. I hate deletionists.
> Delete the garbage
Which is still deletionism.
Re:Wikipedia’s Emergency
by guard-of-terra on Thursday June 06, 2013 @04:59AM
(#5831288)
Why? If they define an article "A blog of John Ass", I just won't read it and my experience would not degrade.
I still get nuclear physics in "Nuclear Physics" article, amn't I?
I can't see how having more articles will make things worse.
> I still get nuclear physics in "Nuclear Physics" article, amn't I?
Not at the same level of quality, because they also won't be deleting the nonsense crank pseudo-science version of "Nuclear Physics" which would confuse you terribly. Deleting crap is one of the best ways to make the project as a whole useful.
Re:Wikipedia’s Emergency
by guard-of-terra on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:17AM
(#5837839)
Well, I won't read that version, I'll only read the "real" one.
Bonus points: journalists and common folk will stop pretending everything in wikipedia is true like they do now.
> Well, I won't read that version, I'll only read the "real" one.
You won't know which is which unless you already know enough to not need to look it up in a general reference such as Wikipedia. That's the point.