Re:Wikipedia’s Emergency
by JoshTriplett on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @07:52PM
(#5829476)
Using nouns rather than verbs in links does not specifically relate to wikis and WikiWords. See this more general advice from the W3C in 2001: http://www.w3.org/QA/Tips/noClickHere.html.en
> we do not recommend putting verb phrases in link text
More generally, links should identify what they link to, and more often than not that will mean a noun phrase, not a verb phrase.
I don't see a problem with most links being nouns and noun phrases. Wikipedia is a reference, not a literary masterwork, and so consistency and the principle of least surprise should be followed. There's also no guideline that I know of that forbids the use of links creatively or intelligently for non-nouns, as long as they wouldn't negatively impact readability.
I also don't believe Wikipedia/Mediawiki has required link labels to match link targets in something like ten years. It's often desirable or necessary to do that purely for semantic reasons.