Funny you should mention Romeo&Juliet. Are you aware that Juliet was 13, and Romeo probably around 20?
You know, I could be wrong about this, but I'm pretty sure they were also fictional characters, and the actors didn't even have sex on stage?
Sure, but those fictional characters are practically synonyms for romantic love and played thousands of times each year, all over the world, often by teenagers.
And yet, if it happened as originally written, Romeo would be considered worse than any other kind of criminal and a target for lynch mobs, even here on HN.
Romeo would be considered worse than any other kind of criminal and a target for lynch mobs, even here on HN.
Actually no, read the comments on this page. There are many who think that Romeo did nothing really wrong.
Yes, lets keep using a play written in 1590 in this discussion.
So? I did say overtly broad laws were wrong. That doesn't mean that all forms of "someone over 18 having sex with someone under 18 is wrong".
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer”
by warmwaffles on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:23PM
(#5826598)
Nice extremes. Now where does this current story fit in with your argument?
Reforming laws & tactics are not the equivalent of "everything" being thrown out.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer”
by randomdata on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:47PM
(#5827690)
If the circumstances allow both hypothetical parties to be of sound mind to make a consenting decision, and consent was given by both parties, then I see no reason to get upset over it. Why should I be able to tell consenting people what they can and cannot do?
It is certainly not my place to project my feelings onto someone else. Perhaps even projecting my desire for consent might be crossing the line. Definitely an interesting topic with no fully answered questions.
Sure, there can be problems with laws that have zero flexibilites (like a 17½yr old having sex with their 18 year old partner), but that doesn't mean everything should be thrown out.