News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by elorant on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @08:50AM (#5825195)
What about nuclear waste though? You end up with some tons of radioactive material which you have to store in high-security underground facilities with the hope that in some time in the future humanity will find a way to dispose it in a safer way.
Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by justatdotin on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @09:03AM (#5825246)
G'day mate, here in australia we're leading the world in nuclear waste storage. After giving our best scientists 30 years to spend on the question, we've finally brought it to a head, and are in the process of unveiling a state of the art solution.

here's what we've done: found a remote and isolated spot of land in the middle of a 3000km long highway. we've paid a pittance and reminded the small local indigenous community who actually own the land that they don't have any political, economic or social power. Their economic disempowerment was exacerbated a couple of years after they were targetted, when new apartheid-style laws quarantined welfare to natives. Their political disempowerment was reinforced by unprecedented laws that negate their rights as land owners and remove any possible legal obstacle to the dump plan.

Right, so with the social engineering out of the way, let's get into the nuts and bolts: we're gonna grade a dirt road onto a dry patch of land, and build a barbed wire shed. to hold the most highly radioactive nuclear wastes we produce.

I'm sure before too long the rest of the world will get on side to endorse the engineering, and of course site selection.

As we say down under, she'll be right mate!

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by peterpathname on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @09:39PM (#5829859)
"The idea that the best way to promote economic advancement in the Northern Territory is to post six of the loneliest security guards in the country to guard against people tampering with radioactive waste for the next three centuries absolutely beggars belief. They waved around a $12 million cheque in the community, north of Tennant Creek, which wanted a decent road and some community education support for their kids. That $12 million cheque was dangled in their faces in exchange for hosting what they thought was going to be a rubbish dump."

http://scott-ludlam.greensmps.org.au/content/speeches/aborig...

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by colinshark on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:06AM (#5825618)
The problem of radioactive waste...

Let's put it this way:

In exchange for clean, constant, domestically sourced, almost unlimited energy for an entire year, each person must dispose of or store their waste, which is the size of...

A pill of aspirin.

You could just put it in a little lead jar. That's all the waste. The alternative is fossil fuel waste, which would be...

10 tons of CO2 (volume = 5 American houses) which floats into the atmosphere, plus 2 tons of coal ash.

Of course, everyone can just pool their resources and put all the radioactive waste together. I don't consider it to be a very serious or unsolvable problem.

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by juandopazo on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:19AM (#5825710)
> The alternative is fossil fuel waste

You make it sounds as if there were no other alternative.

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by mpyne on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:39AM (#5825855)
For baseload power? There effectively isn't. Renewable energy generation requires a substantial investment in energy storage systems if you don't have thermal power generation (such as nuclear or fossil-fueled plants), as having rolling blackouts just because the wind unexpectedly isn't blowing as hard is not good for business.
Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by Pxtl on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:05AM (#5826058)
The thing is that nuclear isn't really good at this. Nuclear plants don't have much in the way of a throttle - they're just "on" or "complete shut-down and it will take substantial measures to start it up again". Fossil fuels or some sort of capacitive system (even just using the peak surpluses to pump water into a reservoir above a turbine) would do that task better.

The panicky nay-sayers of nuclear power are too obsessed with the risks of radiation, but there are a lot of other legitimate reasons that it might not have a place in our future. Uranium just isn't that plentiful, for example.

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by TeMPOraL on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:26AM (#5826227)
> Nuclear plants don't have much in the way of a throttle - they're just "on" or "complete shut-down and it will take substantial measures to start it up again".

Well, this is exactly what we need. Power demand is fluctuating, but mostly averages out to something constant. It's easier to throw in a little buffering to compensate demand fluctuations than to wake up with half the power in the grid because it suddenly got cloudy. You'd have to store very large amounts of power, which is this "substantial investment in energy storage systems" GP was writing about.

> Uranium just isn't that plentiful, for example.

Here you are wrong.

http://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_162.shtml

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by mpyne on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:52AM (#5826381)
> The thing is that nuclear isn't really good at this. Nuclear plants don't have much in the way of a throttle - they're just "on" or "complete shut-down and it will take substantial measures to start it up again".

Nuclear can certainly be designed to ramp power output up or down in response to demand. After all there are many applications of nuclear technology in fields that require rapid and immediate changes in power output.

Nuclear power generation plants are not typically designed to do this, but it's not because nuclear can't, it's because nuclear doesn't have to. The plants are built by the utility companies to act as baseload power generation and can normally afford to take hours to change power output if they wish. But if utility plants wanted a nuke plant that would change power output quicker, that could be arranged as well.

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by sentenza on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:28PM (#5826640)
It's likely that baseload and renewables will meet half way. Supposedly, adding a small amount of battery capacity to wind turbines dramatically increases their power output predictability.

http://www.technologyreview.com/news/514331/wind-turbines-ba...

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by TeMPOraL on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:25AM (#5826214)
Not to mention the fact that the power grid would fry under such variable power supply conditions.
Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by Symmetry on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @09:19AM (#5825336)
Well, the really radioactive parts of the waste will decay after a fairly short number of years. With regards to the less radioactive, slower decaying part I'm not sure why we worry about it so much more than naturally occurring radioactive substances. There are streams in Colorado that are measurably radioactive because they interact with natural Uranium deposits but the levels are low enough to not pose a real public health hazard. I don't see why buried man-made radioactive substances are unacceptable when buried natural radioactive substances aren't.
Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by Xylakant on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @06:04PM (#5828971)
Because for example plutonium has that nasty tendency to go boom once you amass a kilo or so, so safe storage is required to keep all lunatics at bay. It's also a very potent poison. It's also not found in natural deposits.
Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by kmm on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:21AM (#5825726)
Nuclear waste is stored very, very deep and secure. I cannot imagine future humans having the technology to open these up, without knowing what is in there. Either we lose all of our knowledge and no soul will ever see that site, or we stay an advanced civilization and we are warned of the dangers before opening the nuclear waste facilities.

Don't forget that uranium is found naturally in the ground, in geologically vastly more unstable regions, with water flowing through it. What we're doing is concentrating the radioactivity, and putting it deeper and safer. If you're afraid of mankind finding these waste sites in the future, are you not afraid of them finding uranium in their drinking water?

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by _delirium on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:30AM (#5825793)
> Nuclear waste is stored very, very deep and secure.

Ideally it would be. But in many cases in practice, that isn't the case, because those facilities have either not been built, or not opened. In the U.S., since the long-planned Yucca Mountain facility has never opened, most nuclear waste is stored on-site at the reactor complex, in above-ground facilities. For the first few years it's immersed in cooling pools [1], and then subsequently is parked in metal/concrete cylinders [2]. This is considered interim storage awaiting final burial in geologically stable vaults, but without Yucca Mountain the "interim" storage has become de-facto permanent.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spent_fuel_pool

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dry_cask_storage

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by kgarten on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:37AM (#5825840)
In Germany half is currently stored in an old salt mine which is at risk of water breaking in (in a region with seismic activity) ... the other half sits in bright daylight under tin roofs (not my definition of very very deep ... :)
Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by Xylakant on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:03AM (#5826040)
Even worse - the risk is not water breaking in, since that's already happening. The risk is total collapse and contamination of the ground water: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asse_II_mine

So now the plan is to retrieve all the waste and store it - this time better at an estimated cost of at least 4 - 6 billion Euro.

The general problem I have with nuclear power is that it's all fine and dandy as long as everything goes as planned. If not, then everything goes boom in a big way. And where humans and profits are involved, plans tend not to involve all failure modes: The explosions in fukushima could have been avoided using catalytic recombinators which are for example mandatory in germany [1].

[1] http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaktorsicherheit#T.C3.B6pfer-K... (sorry, german)

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by Pxtl on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:01AM (#5826026)
You can't make this argument in a vacuum. You need to compare it to the alternatives - most energy today is generated by burning fossil fuels, which might be the way to a global environmental apocalypse. An old mine containing dangerous chemicals seems pretty mild compared to depopulating Mexico.

Now obviously 100% clean means like wind and solar are preferred, but are those really viable at a global level?

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by nemof on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @09:02AM (#5825242)
one possibility which has never seen the light of day:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_Fast_Reactor#Nuclear_w...

Re:Japan's radiation disaster toll: none dead, none sick by scythe on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @08:53AM (#5825205)
On the plus side, we are really good at it:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X697yZBCN8w