Re:Why are determinants defined the weird way they are?
by ColinWright on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @06:48AM
(#5824696)
Frequently when taught, people are shown how to compute a determinant, and shown some uses of a determinant, but never really figure out what it "is".
This says - "Here are some useful properties that we want something to have, let's derive what that thing is. Ah, this is what we call a determinant."
It's not that it's circular, or back-to-front, it's just trying to give additional context and motivation.
Re:Why are determinants defined the weird way they are?
by cousin_it on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @07:23AM
(#5824839)
It might be even easier to understand without mentioning parallelepipeds. If you apply the matrix to each point of an arbitrarily shaped object, the resulting object's volume will be multiplied by the determinant of the matrix, possibly with a minus sign if orientation is reversed.
The 'property' can be one of many.
The most 'obvious' being that the only 'coherent' way to define 'area', 'volume', etc... so that it behaves 'linearly' [i.e. correctly for parallelepipeds] ends up being quite 'complicated' but quite useful at the same time and it receives a name.
As it happens, it turns out to be quite useful for theoretically solving linear equations as well (although NOT for real-world solving them).
So... It is not weird, it is what it is because it happens to be that way and then it receives a name.
There are much weirder things you can do with a matrix which do not have a specific name. Determinants have because they are useful.