News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by DanBC on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @10:50PM (#5823408)
>Flywheels do not produce energy, they store kinetic energy.

The article says, twice, that his design both stores and generates energy. Have they got something wrong? I'm aware that they're using the term 'flywheel' pretty broadly, and his newer device might not be a traditional flywheel. They use scare-quotes a couple of times when using the term flywheel, so they seem to be saying it's not a flywheel.

> His latest project -- perfecting a prototype of his lightweight "flywheel," a cylindrical, rotating battery -- could revolutionize the energy industry, storing and creating energy better than any conventional electrobattery on the planet.

> Post has been called the "father of the modern flywheel," a title he dismisses as "too generous." The rapidly spinning devices not only store energy with minimal losses, but they also generate it.

The relevance is also mentioned in the story - he wanted to "apply physics to help solve the world's energy problems" and banks of these in power stations might help. Isn't storing the excess power generated by solar farms during the day a problem? Couldn't something like this help with that?

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by ars on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @11:21PM (#5823508)
You can't just generate energy from nothing. A flywheel stores energy, it doesn't create it. So yes, they got something wrong.
Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by whatshisface on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @11:32PM (#5823534)
"We said, 'To heck with electromagnetic, we're going with electrostatic,'" Post says, laughing.

It's clearly not just a normal flywheel, perhaps it can convert some other energy form into electricity? (We call them "generators" don't we?)

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by ars on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:27AM (#5823875)
Other form of energy? Like what?

Using electrostatics to pump up the flywheel is certainly interesting (I wish the article had even the slightest detail on it), but it still doesn't create energy. (Or collect energy from some untapped resource.)

Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by mc-lovin on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:10AM (#5823820)
I'd guess that phrase refers to how energy is put into and taken out of the flywheel: using electrostatic force rather than electromagnetic.
Re:Livermore scientist still reinventing the wheel at 94 by EEGuy on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:26AM (#5823871)
I'm intrigued by Dr. Post's statement regarding electrostatic rather than electromagnetic force.

When I think of the "motor-generator" component of a flywheel-based energy storage device, coils and magnetic poles and all that electromagnetic to/from mechanical energy conversion stuff comes to my mind.

Electrostatic to/from mechanical energy conversion is known [1] [2], but not to my knowledge known for sustained high power and energy density appropriate for practical flywheel-based energy storage.

Intriguing to consider that Dr. Post's research might be going in such a non-traditional direction as electrostatic motor-generators. Perhaps there are some incremental efficiency gains or design simplifications to be had in using the flat plates, good insulation and high voltages characteristic of electrostatics instead of the big coils, cores and high currents of electromagnetics.

That said, there's no free lunch: No matter which electrical-to-mechanical-to-electrical energy conversion mode used may be, the energy stored remains rotational kinetic energy, thus limited by the same critical physical limitations (failure modes, maximal energy density, maximal power density) of traditional (electromagnetic, to date) flywheels.

--------

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrostatic_motor

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrostatic_generator