This is why I was dumbfounded by the call for "innovation" in medical industry at the end of the post. There's plenty of innovation is going on, it's the corruption and extortion we're looking at here: $60K were simply extorted from a person in pain.
It's a legislation+law enforcement issue.
Or more specifically from all of us. The author only paid $2400. The whole system is designed to be opaque and non-competitive so they can just bill insurance companies for whatever. I wonder what it would have cost if he said he was paying in cash (hint: a lot less).
Individuals paying cash (and individuals without insurance) are generally stuck with the "sticker" price for care (higher than what private insurers pay, and significantly higher than what medicare pays (medicare basically gets to "declare" what they're willing to pay for a given procedure and hospitals generally have to go along with it or they'll lose some/all federal funding)).
It's usually very difficult to renegotiate the sticker price without an insurance provider or the government working on your behalf. If it's a time sensitive or life threatening procedure, you'll often have other more pressing action items than haggling over the price. It's even harder to negotiate after the fact, since hospitals make you sign away whatever bargaining rights you may have had before they'll agree to treat you.
[edit]
Finally, hospitals generate the bulk of their revenue from insured patients. They can and do quote higher prices to uninsured patients, but the fact remains that this is a fairly risky patient pool for the hospital, since many of these patients will sign whatever they need to sign in order to get treatment, despite being completely unable to pay the (relatively huge) prices quoted.
Hospitals have incentives to keep this pool as small as possible, and occasionally resort to extreme measures (legal or otherwise) to get rid of these patients [1]. Though the hospitals often aren't able to collect the full price from many of these patients, you would be naive to believe that they won't send collections agencies after you and utterly ruin your credit rating if you find yourself unable to pay.
It always amazed me that in the US the health of a person is not a right and if you get hurt doing anything you have to pay huge fees.
But don't let me get in the way of your 30 seconds of hate...
Person 1: "You should pay for your own care"
Person 2: "What if you are poor and can't?"
Person 1: "Sucks to be you."
With the possible addendum of: Person 1: "But charity organizations will cover
the costs for those that can't pay,
because then I can choose of my own
will to put money towards the cause."
Person 2: "What if not enough people donate?"
Person 1: "Well, it sucks to be poor."
[I'll note that "sucks to be you" as an answer could probably be translated as, "I have not thought out my position that far, and I don't like you challenging my views, so I'll give you a short and curt answer."]It would be great if we can talk about the origin of these health costs without getting entangled into who should be paying them. But maybe that's an impossible task.
The Libertarian-in-Chief Ron Paul himself a Physician who claims that the exhorbitant costs in health care are a more recent phenomenon. He quotes how much his costs were to do house-visits (remarkably small), and compares that with the ballooning in costs more recently. While one can argue that Libertarianism is a Utopic view, the rapidly escalating prices of healthcare are not something that is espoused by Libertarian philosophy. I.e. Low health costs and individual responsibility for health paying are not incompatible. Then again, neither are low health costs and universal health coverage. Right now, we have the worst of both worlds: high health costs and individual responsibility for payment.
[1] http://big.assets.huffingtonpost.com/hospital-procedure-cost...
Indeed, if there was such a direct correlation between the two, the easiest way to control healthcare costs would be to reduce doctoral school tuition rates. Clearly, this is not a viable solution here because the two are not directly correlated.
Now, it is true that Tuition Costs have risen at a much higher rate since 1960 than Health Care costs on a percentage basis compared to inflation [1] [2] [3], but in aggregate the actual health care costs on a per-individual basis dwarf total tuition costs as part of household income [4].
[1] https://lh3.ggpht.com/-dqm5PIPoC58/Ti8HKy2jjrI/AAAAAAAAPgU/W...
[2] http://chartingtheeconomy.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/hea...
[3] http://cdn.theatlanticwire.com/img/upload/2011/08/aw-chart-c...
[4] http://static2.businessinsider.com/image/4d775519ccd1d571150...
I'm merely pointing out that this is a complex beast with many contributing factors:
- The money/time investment to become a medical professional.
- The increase in the number / complexity of procedures over the years. Our medical knowledge keeps increasing we keep getting more and more ways to fix things.
- Comparisons without details. For example, people like to compare how cheap MRIs are in Japan, but the MRIs that people get in Japan aren't as powerful/accurate as the ones that are charged for in the US. Does this justify the cost difference? Maybe, but maybe not.
I think we actually agree here - the dramatic rise in health care costs doesn't have a single root cause, or even perhaps a readily identifiable root cause. It's systemic, rather than simplistic. Education is a factor, but a small one. Insurance and health liabilities are probably an equal factor. But neither explain disparities in cost within the US (no need to look at comparisons between Japan for that). See my [1] reference two comment posts up for the chart on cost disparities intra-US.
It's quite possible that medical suppliers are using information asymmetry to overcharge in some instances and properly charge in others. Could it be as simple as that? Why is it that the same procedure with the same equipment using similarly trained staff in similar hospitals with similar liability exposures would have such different costs? The only thing I can think of is that medical purchasing is sufficiently complex and with such little visibility and transparency between different establishments that medical suppliers and providers can get away with pricing them "as much as the market can support". But that's just an unsubstantiated theory and maybe there is a reason why the same procedure is cheaper in another state, county, or city.
Are doctor's costs more expensive in CA due to the increased cost of living? Ditto for administrators, driving up the hospital costs? Is it due to a scarcity of hospital beds / operating tables that the hospital charges 'what the market will bear' in more densely populated regions?
If the doctor sends you to get lab work, the lab has its own person that fills that role. If the doctor sends you to a specialist, ditto.
Of course the insurance companies have their own hordes of employees who write all the rules of who pays what under what circumstances, keep the books of all the patients' deductibles and all the providers' bills, etc.
None of these employees does anything economically productive. They just move money around.
Obamacare requires that people buy health insurance, which protects this bureaucracy with a legal mandate to purchase their services, and creates more bureaucracy, on the government side, to administer the law.
However, I still don't go base jumping. Even if the costs are covered, I still don't want to spend six months in traction after I break my back because the parachute didn't open. Similarly almost all the people I know either don't smoke, or want to stop smoking, because even if you can do it free of charge lung cancer just isn't much fun.
If you hurt yourself and someone patchs you up, its not the same, my reconstructed knee will never feel the same as the other.
I think that you pose people that whant to benefit as much as they can from the state, and I think that I know noneone that does that, at least in health care, nobody wants to go the hospital
Now whether the people with this syndrome are sizable enough to make it unacceptable to just bear their cost is another story...
There are debates about how much "defensive medicine" adds to the cost, but those aren't all that relevant here since the costs presented are exclusive of additional tests, etc.
$7,638 per person per year. That just can't be right. I and 90% of the people I know haven't made a significant trip to the dr or hospital in years. Where the fuck is that money going?
See: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1361028 (Table 3). 80% of your lifetime healthcare expenditures will be after age 40.
P.S. Thanks to my excellent doctors, Nathan Green and Richard Pitsch...
Even if the people you know were somehow a representative sample, that's not all that surprising. A significant health event can easily cost orders of magnitude more than $7,638, so even if 90% didn't have one in a period of several years, the average cost could still easily be $7,638 per person per year.
My impression is that medical tourism from the U.S. is not typically for cost savings, but rather because particular procedures are either completely unavailable (experimental stem cell treatments) or could require long wait times (liver transplants). I'd love some data on this. Wikipedia's rather poorly written article suggests MT is more popular from countries with socialized systems in order to reduce wait time, but I'm skeptical.
Well, if my options are to spend 60 grand on an ACL repair in the U.S., or significantly less than that on a first-class ticket to London, some serious fun, and an ACL repair...I know which one I would choose.
It is in the insurer's interest for you to go somewhere cheaper as it saves them (not you) money. There are various press articles about this happening such as this 2009 article http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/health/2009-08-22-medica...
- No out of pocket cost
- Free all expenses paid one week trip to England with your surgery
Would cost them the 3k pounds+2.5k$ of your share+maybe another 3k for a good trip..<10k total compared to 60k
I take it they simply can't get that 3k pounds deal as an insurance company.
Because a sizable share of the Americans who could afford even the UK surgery prices plus travel and accommodations to/in the UK also have health insurance which covers the procedure in the US, and makes it cheaper for the patient to have the procedure done in the US even if the total cost is more expensive.
Potential issues with follow up care as one drawback.
Like the OP I had meniscal tearing too so more or less directly comparable. (Although obviously 8 years is probably a long time in medical devices so worth bearing in mind).
To put in perspective, that is approximate the same total cost (~$5000) as just _one_ of the pieces of equipment ("Cannula Fast Fix CVD") that the OP lists.
It's one thing if doctors are more expensive because they have to carry higher insurance charges to protect against negligence lawsuits, etc, but that the equipment alone is multiple times the cost seems crazy.
Mental.