Suppose that there is a tiling of sphere with N hexes. Each hex has 6 edges, but every edge is shared by two hexes, so there are 6N/2 = 3N edges. Similarly, there are 6N/3 = 2N vertices.Thus, the Euler characteristic would be 2N - 3N + N = 0. Now, the sphere has Euler characteristic 2, so we get a contradiction.
Incidentally, a torus has Euler characteristic 0, and indeed it turns out that you can tile torus with hexes.
,
/ \
/___\
/ \ the dots (.,') mark centers of "new"
/ . \ hexagons, each of the ,' would be
/\ /\ "peaks", the one centered on "." would
/__\_____/__\ be "flat".
' '
You'd probably need to subdivide the hexagons further, and decide what those "peaks" should "mean" -- or ignore them... Not sure if that would be easier than using pentagons, though...Another way too look at it, is to say the hexes would be distorted wrt. area -- Not sure if that would matter though...
My goal was trying to get a hex grid, with roughly "ignorable" distortion. I think the most straight forward way would be to use four "pseudo" (irregular) hexagons, and wrap them into a cube (ie: four "hexagons" made from a square and two triangles with 45 and 90 degree angels). You would then have a "round" map that could be subdivided. It would be far from perfect, but very straightforward -- and if mapped onto a planet "north-south" (aka pointy-side up) -- I think it would yield a similar distortion to what we are used to from various map projections:
/\ /\ /\ /\ <- distorted sides
/__\ /__\ /__\ /__\ ________ _______
| A | B | C | D | / /\ |\ c /|
| __ | __ | __ | __ | / N /bb\ |d \ / |
\ / \ / \ / \ / /_______/bbbb\ | /'\b |
\/ \/ \/ \/ \aaaaaaa\bbbb/ |/__a__\|
\aaaaaaa\b / top down view
\_______\/ ("North pole")
When wrapped up into a cube, the south and north poles would lie at the
intersection of the four hexagons. Unless I'm tricking myself, this has
the interesting property that the distance from A to B and D is 1, while
from A to C is 2 -- whichever way you "circumnavigate".Being hexagons, they could be further subdivided into hexagons (as for most purposes this grid would be too coarse).
I'm not convinced it would be very useful as a "proper" map projection -- but might work for a game.
Well, I guess you can just make equal area square map and cut that. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gall%E2%80%93Peters_projection
Also, it's curious nobody mentioned Battle of Wesnoth. Battle of Wesnoth (together with Fantasy General and Battle Isle) is a shining example of hex-based strategic wargame.