News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by pron on Saturday June 01, 2013 @08:17PM (#5806689)
Suppose for a moment that Google really is as benevolent as you believe. You yourself admit that they do have a lot of power. In a democracy, we try not to put too much power even in the hands of an elected official. Isn't it a problem that so much power resides with a corporation? Should society trust Google's good intentions?

But I even have doubts about Google's benevolence. What, a company that adopts a "don't be evil" motto is less likely to be evil than a company that doesn't? I'd be suspicious of a person that feels the need to declare that he'll do his best not murder anyone. By adopting the motto, Google had acknowledged the fact that corporations do tend to do evil. But is it because they intend to do so? Do chairmen and CEOs wake up in the morning all giddy about doing some evil or naughty, harmful, mischief today? Even Bernie Madoff didn't start out like this. And yet, corporations do evil in spite of people's best intentions. So Google said: we'll try to be careful. That's actually not bad, because I hope that that slogan makes the Google executives aware of the temptations and pitfalls that await all big firms. But I do not for a second believe that Google's executives are so much better than all other good people running large corporations that actually do evil. Because, hey -- power corrupts.

Nobody likes getting up one day and realize they've become a Bond villain, so they don't: that is, they just don't realize it. Also, nobody really is an actual Bond villain (well, Hitler). Even good people do bad things. My point is, people do need a little help from the outside to protect them from themselves, and with that much power, Google needs a lot of help. Google has become a big problem.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by DannyBee on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:23AM (#5807658)
It's not clear what you are suggesting with the power questions. Breaking up Google?

As for whether society should trust Google's intentions: I hope not. Society should be, in general, distrustful of corporations, and, for the most part, they are. That doesn't mean Google doesn't have good intentions, or that one should assume bad faith everywhere. At the same time, what was questioned originally was the operation of that corporation and it's people, and that's what i responded to :)

As for the adoption of the motto: The original outside publication of this was done while going public, and was intended to make clear to wall street that Google wasn't going to maximize profit at the expense of everything else, where everything else usually involves doing morally questionable things.

I think you read way too much into it.

"But I do not for a second believe that Google's executives are so much better than all other good people running large corporations that actually do evil. Because, hey -- power corrupts."

All I would say to this is I hope you get to meet them some day. Except for one, I can say they really are better than all the other good people i've met running other large corporations. They are honestly good people, and honestly care about doing right.

In the end, I guess we just disagree. I don't believe Google has become a big problem, and I don't think Google needs a lot of help from the outside to protect them from themselves. In fact, I think help from "the outside" would make things a lot worse.

For example, the last time I looked, the outside wants Google to try to detect when people are doing bad things, and report them.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by pron on Sunday June 02, 2013 @04:12AM (#5807734)
they really are better than all the other good people i've met running other large corporations.

Good, so they'll understand that no one, no matter how "good" should have this much power.

I also think that Barack Obama is better than most other politician, and that the US will be much better off -in the short term -- if he were allowed to operate without hindrance from that pesky, annoying, inefficient Congress that's just slowing him down. And yet, checks and balances are a good thing in the long term.

Augustus was a great ruler. Certainly much more efficient and benevolent than the senate. But he did effectively bring the monarchy back, and many of his successors weren't as good as him.

what you are suggesting with the power questions. Breaking up Google?

Yes, although we probably have a little more time (a couple of years, probably) before this becomes absolutely necessary. Also, we need regulation on companies holding personal information:

  - Limitations on what information can be kept.
  - FBI background checks on all employees with access to private information.
  - Top notch cyber security (I'm sure Google does that; no complaints there)
  - Maximum physical security, like access to private information only from certain, constantly monitored physical location.
the outside wants Google to try to detect when people are doing bad things, and report them.

Google doesn't oppose reporting on people because it's evil; they're opposed because it would be really bad for business. And while I do share Assange's concern about government surveillance, I'm much more horrified at the prospect of surveillance by a corporation.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by DannyBee on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:11PM (#5809693)
I don't have time at the moment to reply substantively to the rest, and I don't want to shortchange. However, I will address one thing:

"Google doesn't oppose reporting on people because it's evil; they're opposed because it would be really bad for business. And while I do share Assange's concern about government surveillance, I'm much more horrified at the prospect of surveillance by a corporation."

This is false. I have first hand knowledge of why we oppose it. We oppose it because it's evil. It is bad for business, but that is secondary.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by pron on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:57PM (#5809856)
We oppose it because it's evil

Good. So you probably understand why amassing so much power in one corporation is evil in and of itself, even if the the people at the top have good intentions at the moment (whatever that means - I'm not sure most people share the same definition of good intentions).

The intentions of many influential people in government, including those at the very top, are not in the least bit less noble than those of Google's executives, and yet, while they may not always like it, they understand the necessity for checks and balances. Power must not be concentrated. Concentrated power is either evil, naivety or ignorance. It can never, ever-ever, be good, though it might have the appearance of good for a short while.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by cbsmith on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:59PM (#5809872)
> In a democracy, we try not to put too much power even in the hands of an elected official. Isn't it a problem that so much power resides with a corporation?

No, it really isn't. If you pretend for a minute that Google is a hive mind, with a single individual in control of its actions, it still doesn't have a power to match the federal government of the US, or even the President (who is a single elected official).

You keep going down this track and pretty soon you are arguing that you can't have capitalism and democracy at the same time.

> But I do not for a second believe that Google's executives are so much better than all other good people running large corporations that actually do evil. Because, hey -- power corrupts.

The Don't Be Evil principle is actually a check on precisely this concern. By having it as a principle, it invites the executives to be challenged on this basis by everyone in the company. That is the entire point. Having a motto Don't Be Evil doesn't magically change the nature of your executive team. What it changes is how that team is challenged.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by rhizome on Saturday June 01, 2013 @09:02PM (#5806814)
Should society trust Google's good intentions?

I would question whether society even knows enough about Google's intentions to be able to judge them as good or bad.