News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by scholia on Saturday June 01, 2013 @06:29PM (#5806310)
Google also avoids paying tax on its huge UK earnings by shuffling the money between countries. That's presumably legal but it certainly isn't moral or ethical.

Obviously Google is not the only company that does this. Apple and other capitalist corporations do the same thing. But it's one thing to run a company based on naked greed and quite another to claim that you're somehow superior.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by mitchty on Saturday June 01, 2013 @07:23PM (#5806510)
To be fair, corporations legally avoiding as much taxation as possible is a bit of a stretch for the evil claim. Corporate ethics wise it is more interesting why consumers want corporations to pay more tax as it effectively increases prices.

A better question would be posed to our governments on tax reform and simplification. But we all know the loopholes exist somewhat intentionally, otherwise they would have been closed already. The fact they're not getting closed indicates that our perception of what a company should pay and what they're legally obligated is basically wrong.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by threeseed on Saturday June 01, 2013 @09:20PM (#5806861)

   why consumers want corporations to pay more tax as it effectively increases prices.
Simple. When was the last time you bought a 787 jet, tractor, industrial window washer or ordered 1000 tonnes of concrete ? People want ALL corporations to pay more taxes and are fine if the few products that they do buy are a tiny bit more expensive.

The fact is that most 'adults' understand that taxes pay for essential services such as education, infrastructure and health care. And during the tough times we live in aren't happy those services are being cut whilst corporations are making huge profits.

Remember this is people's day to day lives we are talking about.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by mitchty on Saturday June 01, 2013 @11:15PM (#5807145)
Sure but my general question remains. Why do we denigrate the actors that are working in their own interests based on the incentives as given, when the denigration is the tax codes, and implicitly the people that create the tax codes that are the problems?

I'm not arguing that paying more tax isn't inherently beneficial towards the state(s), but if the incentive is to avoid the tax, and it is legal, I fail to see the problem at all from the viewpoint of the corporation.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by scholia on Sunday June 02, 2013 @06:58PM (#5810425)
> I fail to see the problem at all from the viewpoint of the corporation.

You're right, as long as the corporation doesn't mind if the public see it as a bunch of greedy, grasping, evil corporate bastards.

In Google's case, its "selling point" is "Don't be evil" and its business depends on trust. It's rapidly losing that trust.

For the record, Google's UK turnover in 2011 was £2.7bn, and based on its profitability, it's making about £676m and should be paying more than £180m in tax in that one year. In fact, it has paid a total of £10 million between 2006 and 2011 on revenues of £11.9bn.

If Google was a moral, ethical company then it would pay taxes that cover the cost of doing business in the UK, where it benefits from UK government expenditure on maintaining the country as a good place to do business (roads, schools, health services, police etc).

Essentially, Google is using fancy international book-keeping to defraud the British public.

That's evil in my book, whatever Google thinks.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by vixen99 on Sunday June 02, 2013 @06:17AM (#5807953)
But we must take account of the numbers. As Orwell might put it, 'some tax, good, more tax - double plus good'. Not exactly true is it? On the whole, (and this is not a zero tax argument) the following from Milton Friedman seems a truism to me.

“When a man spends his own money to buy something for himself, he is very careful about how much he spends and how he spends it.When a man spends his own money to buy something for someone else,he is still very careful about how much he spends, but somewhat less what he spends it on. When a man spends someone else's money to buy something for himself, he is very careful about what he buys, but doesn't care at all how much he spends. And when a man spends someone else's money on someone else, he doesn't care how much he spends or what he spends it on. And that's government for you.”

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by M2Ys4U on Saturday June 01, 2013 @08:14PM (#5806677)
>Corporate ethics wise it is more interesting why consumers want corporations to pay more tax as it effectively increases prices.

Because taxes (help) pay for the negative externalities that arise from the corporation doing business.

>A better question would be posed to our governments on tax reform and simplification. But we all know the loopholes exist somewhat intentionally, otherwise they would have been closed already. The fact they're not getting closed indicates that our perception of what a company should pay and what they're legally obligated is basically wrong.

The problem exists because of the international tax framework, and getting the governments of all the jurisdictions involved to reform the tax system is harder than a single country unilaterally doing so - especially when it greatly benefits some countries at the expense of others.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by mitchty on Saturday June 01, 2013 @11:24PM (#5807163)
Agreed, I'm not saying tax reform will be easy. Just noting that blaming corporations for exploiting, though thats a bit of a loaded term, perhaps advantageously utilizing existing tax structures is a bit naive. The incentives currently mean a corporation would be wrong to ignore tax breaks, that coupled with for example the corporate tax rate for money repatriation in America for example means that less tax income is generated at current law interpretation.

Basically is 35% of 0 dollars better than 10% of N dollars? In the US that is effectively our current dilema is it not? Our tax rates for certain things are so high people have no incentive to get double taxed in two disparate countries so they leave the money outside of any taxable entity. Improving the incentives to bring money back would seem to be a no brainer as it is a bit of a win/win situation to both sides.

As to disparities amongst countries, I'm not sure there ever could be a solution outside of some overreaching treaty agreements. Past that I'm sure there will always be a Caymans willing to lower their costs at the expense of the rest.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by ippisl on Sunday June 02, 2013 @05:22AM (#5807853)
One solution to avoid the need to coordinate between countries is tax access to markets, meaning just use VAT. Of course there will be a need to collaborate on equal taxes between states.

But as people said here the loopholes are probably deliberate.

Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by minwcnt5 on Saturday June 01, 2013 @09:09PM (#5806834)
What's the moral and ethical amount of taxes they should be paying, then? And who decides what that amount should be?
Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by threeseed on Saturday June 01, 2013 @09:23PM (#5806872)
I think most people would agree that where the line gets crossed is when products bought in one country e.g. UK have taxes applied in another country e.g. Ireland.
Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by TeMPOraL on Saturday June 01, 2013 @07:38PM (#5806560)
I read once that there was a debate or something in UK about tax avoidance, and the official stand was that if a company can find and exploit a way to reduce taxation, they are entirely in their right to do so. Can't find the source though.
Re:The Banality of ‘Don’t Be Evil’ by sigzero on Saturday June 01, 2013 @07:27PM (#5806523)
Mitchy - we are not talking about avoiding taxes. We are talking about evading taxes. The "Don't be evil" gets a little tarnished with that.