News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why a veteran web developer finally turned to OS-native apps by mmahemoff on Saturday June 01, 2013 @06:21PM (#5806271)
Actually, I think the case for web gets even more compelling with Meteor, where you can really share components across both sides of the wire.

As I alluded to at the end, the web case makes a lot of sense for companies with unique services who want to roll out across platforms. e.g. If you're a corporate insurance broker, you have a few hundred users who just want some conveniences from native apps, that's a good case for HTML5.

Another example I saw recently is an agency making "viral" apps. Just one-time apps for short contests and so on, and they can do a great job with HTML5.

Deep-level integration though needs native, whether you like Obj-C or not.

Re:Why a veteran web developer finally turned to OS-native apps by ilaksh on Saturday June 01, 2013 @06:38PM (#5806341)
Yes Meteor is very amazing. Of course they have another HTML5 thing in WebRTC that when it becomes well supported (actually fairly soon in Firefox and Chrome) has peer-to-peer data capabilities that for many applications supersede server-based models. Of course, I know that for some applications, that won't be workable, and there are problems to solve, but I believe that most of the problems with synchronization and data ownership have reasonable solutions in peer environments.

I am still hoping that PhoneGap/Cordova will work out ok for my next 'native' app. Have you found that it isn't adequate?

Re:Why a veteran web developer finally turned to OS-native apps by mmahemoff on Saturday June 01, 2013 @06:50PM (#5806393)
I'm the OP, so yes, I found it inadequate :). For a podcast app, even using PhoneGap (rather than browser-based web app) would lead to several issues:

* Hard or impossible to do rich, interactive widgets, notifications, and lock-screen in HTML5

* Unclear path for downloading and saving large files. (Might be possible, but again would need native bridges or native code; forget about Ajax and offline HTML5 storage.)

* Mediocre UI. If you work hard at it, you can build a reasonable UI, but one of the feedbacks we got from reviews and reporters is how they like the way we implemented Android's Holo look-and-feel. A lot of people feel an emotional attachment to their OS and appreciate apps that fit within the guidelines.