News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Unschooling Manifesto by amalcon on Sunday April 26, 2009 @03:12PM (#580300)
There's an idea I've been rolling around in my head for a while, wherein some portion of the day (say an hour) for each class would be dedicated to each student of one grade teaching one of the next younger grade (so two hours per day total per student, one teaching, one being taught). The idea has a lot of potential, both because it helps the educational system scale and provides much-needed individual attention. Individual attention is useful even if it comes from poor teachers. It's much too radical to be implemented in a modern public education system (too much politics there).

The reason I found this interesting is that it gives something to do with class size disparity: have the "best" students in the oversized class work in an independent study format for that hour. It's so simple.

Re:An Unschooling Manifesto by gruseom on Sunday April 26, 2009 @04:03PM (#580368)
I would do something like this if I were running a school as well. There are many obvious benefits to having older kids help younger kids. Besides, partitioning large groups of children by age is a weird idea if you think about it from a human point of view (as opposed to an industrial one).
Re:An Unschooling Manifesto by dangrover on Sunday April 26, 2009 @05:13PM (#580447)
I think the real test of learning something is being able to teach it to others.

I used to volunteer teaching after-school middle school classes with an organization called Citizen Schools and one big part of their methodology was trying to get kids to demonstrate their knowledge and pass it on to others in the end of whatever lesson they were doing.

Re:An Unschooling Manifesto by gruseom on Sunday April 26, 2009 @05:26PM (#580464)
Absolutely, to teach something doesn't only test your mastery of a subject, it helps reinforce it.

I've noticed that in the case of the older child, it reinforces their identity as "someone who knows about X", which feeds back into their own further study of X. It also subtly evokes responsible behavior from the older child simply by putting them in a responsible position, and harnesses the younger child's tendency to look up to older kids in service of their learning. Seems like the kind of thing we ought to do more of.

Re:An Unschooling Manifesto by eru on Monday April 27, 2009 @07:08AM (#581184)
Sounds good. I'd think hard about how to assign mates, though. Perhaps just letting students choose their teacher/pupil would work. Some kids would get more than one pupil, other's none.

Or you'd better do a lottery to assign children 1-on-1.

Further experiments are needed.