Re:The Portuguese Experiment: Did Drug Decriminalization Work?
by randomtask on Sunday April 26, 2009 @01:19PM
(#580172)
I don't think having an opinion should preclude anyone from producing these kind of reports or reduce their persuasiveness. Personally I'd prefer to read a report from an organisation, such as the CATO institute whose political opinions are well known to me, than an "independent" government commission. At least then I know where they stand.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Portuguese Experiment: Did Drug Decriminalization Work?
by marcusbooster on Sunday April 26, 2009 @01:22PM
(#580176)
Exactly, I know where they stand -- so I know to take whatever their findings with a grain of salt. What's that old adage about stats again?
Re:The Portuguese Experiment: Did Drug Decriminalization Work?
by anigbrowl on Sunday April 26, 2009 @04:04PM
(#580371)
This is an intellectually lazy position, like dismissing a the findings of a scientific paper on the basis that the authors began with a hypothesis and sought evidence of its truth. Of course that happens, which is why the quality of sources and methodology should be taken into account.
I haven't real the full paper yet, but the sourcing is impeccable, using government statistics and peer-reviewed papers rather than private surveys or anecdotal evidence.
Re:The Portuguese Experiment: Did Drug Decriminalization Work?
by philwelch on Sunday April 26, 2009 @08:59PM
(#580664)
"What's that old adage about stats again?"
I think "he uses statistics as a drunk man uses a lightpost, for support rather than illumination" is apropos here.
Re:The Portuguese Experiment: Did Drug Decriminalization Work?
by billswift on Sunday April 26, 2009 @03:17PM
(#580306)
How about "People who generically object to statistics KNOW their own position can't be rationally supported."
Re:The Portuguese Experiment: Did Drug Decriminalization Work?
by marcusbooster on Sunday April 26, 2009 @07:50PM
(#580605)
I haven't said anything about their stats or methodologies, but I don't know how you can outright dismiss the reputation of the organization when accessing those very things.