News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:25PM (#5796107)
What's up with "global warming" these days? I was under the impression that, since there hasn't been any recent evidence of warming, everybody had just substituted the more general term "climate change" to deal with anthropogenic environmental stuff.

I'm really crossing my fingers that preventing anthropogenic global warming is as simple as banning CFCs. A lot of the CO2 emission control schemes being considered could seriously stress the economy.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:01PM (#5796246)
>A lot of the CO2 emission control schemes being considered could seriously stress the economy.

A lot of the CO2 emission control schemes being considered are lame.

The key to reducing CO2 is to commit to a policy that will affect the energy market in a gradual, predictable way: A slow phase in of a carbon tax. Raise the carbon tax the equivalent of $0.25/gallon every year, forever. No increase in the year the tax passes.

That means no economic effect this year. No change at all -- except that everyone now expects gas to be $5/gallon in four years, so if you're buying a car now you better get something with an electric motor on it. If you're investing in energy you better invest in renewables rather than petroleum. And then by the time the gas tax is $1 higher than it is now, the installed base of cars has been replaced with higher efficiency ones, so the burden of the tax is already mitigated because a) you're now buying less gas, and b) so is everyone else, so demand goes down, so the pre-tax price of gas goes down and cancels out a significant portion of the tax.

Meanwhile the government collects a large pile of cash (largely at the expense of oil company profits -- what a shame) that can be used to subsidize the installation of renewable energy generating capacity, which creates jobs etc. etc.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:01PM (#5796444)
Your central argument rests on anthropogenic, CO2-caused global warming being irrefutably true. This statement is not yet known to be certain, and the reality is that the economic effect of such an infinitely-increasing tax must be weighed against the risk of that statement being wrong.

Your proposition is example of exactly the extremist control scheme I was talking about.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:11PM (#5796475)
>Your central argument rests on anthropogenic, CO2-caused global warming being irrefutably true.

Nonsense. There is in any event finitely much petroleum in the ground. Even if CO2-caused global warming is complete rubbish, it is still preferable to transition to renewable energy in a gradual fashion rather than hitting a global price spike that would induce an enormous economic catastrophe when a supply panic occurs at a time when all the world's infrastructure is still tooled for fossil fuels.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:17PM (#5796498)
>hitting a global price spike

Again, this is not a certainty. Prices may very likely rise gradually on their own, allowing market forces to dictate a shift towards renewables. No reason to get incompetent bureaucrats involved

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:24PM (#5796520)
Why does it have to be a certainty rather than a significant risk we can insure against?
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:29PM (#5796535)
That's not unreasonable, but there should be proper risk management involved first. The decision is too important to leave up to scare tactics and knee-jerk reactions.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by gwright on Thursday May 30, 2013 @11:57PM (#5796753)
It isn't reasonable to think that oil will suddenly become unavailable leading to an abrupt price spike. Instead, the cost to extract the oil will increase over time causing the market to adjust via lower demand or substitute products.

The 'invisible hand of the market' will have no problem in directing a transition. The recent increase in oil production due to fracking and horizontal drilling is a perfect example of the market directing investment in response to an increase in price.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by simonster on Thursday May 30, 2013 @11:31PM (#5796679)
How likely does it need to be that we will destroy the world in the next century due to our present energy policy before it is worth the economic cost to change it? (I'm pretty sure most people wouldn't say 100%...)
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by ams6110 on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:35PM (#5796363)
Your electric car simply transfers the carbon emissions from the tailpipe to the local powerplant smokestacks (unless your utility uses nukes).
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by epistasis on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:45PM (#5796402)
Where does this misconception come from? Isn't it obvious that large electric power plants are far more efficient than the tiny internal combustion engines?

Running an electric car on pure coal is more CO2 efficient than any gasoline car out there. And it's easy to switch to cleaner electricity sources.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by baddox on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:52PM (#5796591)
> Running an electric car on pure coal is more CO2 efficient than any gasoline car out there.

That claim is contentious. http://elpc.org/plug-ins#4

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by epistasis on Saturday June 01, 2013 @12:14PM (#5804551)
Maybe I'm having serious reading difficulties, but I believe your link refutes your claim:

>Multiple studies have shown that EVs and PHEVs reduce total pollution compared with conventional gasoline or diesel-fueled vehicles, even when batteries are charged with electricity from coal plants.

I've run the numbers myself several times (simply Google for 1. coal's CO2 output per KWH, 2. miles/KWH, 3. CO2 output per gallon of gasoline), and coal-EV has always come out as a super CO2 efficient way to travel, the equivalent of a 50-60 MPG/car, if I recall correctly.

Do you have any sources of contention for that?

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by jvm on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:46PM (#5796405)
He's suggesting a carbon tax. That means you can expect low-carbon energy sources to slowly win out price-wise over high-carbon sources. The electric car will use whatever is economical for the utilities, whereas a gas car is committed to gasoline.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by commanda on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:46PM (#5796408)
Right, but petrol-fueled cars will still emit CO2 regardless of whether the local power plant uses clean energy or not.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by baddox on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:08PM (#5796278)
You forget that the line between "government" and "oil companies" in many countries is a fuzzy one. Most people will either blame this on the oil companies (stereotypical liberal viewpoint) or the government (stereotypical conservative viewpoint), but I prefer to just point out that there's not a big difference between the two.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:19PM (#5796317)
That is a plausible explanation for why it hasn't been done. Do you have any argument for why we shouldn't do it?
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by baddox on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:55PM (#5796593)
I think if there was more separation between oil companies and government (or in general, a decrease in legal power of the oil/government cooperative), then it would be less necessary.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by msandford on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:06PM (#5796268)
Given our government's not very excellent management of Social Security I wouldn't bet on them wisely spending on renewables when there are all kinds of other things the money could be spent on. As such I'm a bit skeptical of your proposal.

EDIT: sarcasm removed

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:17PM (#5796305)
"The government screws everything up" is not an argument, unless the point of the argument is that we shouldn't have a government. We know the government is capable of doing bad things, but unless we intend for them to do nothing whatsoever, the idea is to do what we can to have them do something good rather than something bad.

For example, the problem here is "how can we subsidize renewable energy efficiently." Obviously there are plenty of stupid ways to do that. See: Solyndra. Let me suggest a better alternative: Forget about which companies should get money or qualifications or anything of that nature. Just take the money from the tax and give it to the people generating electricity from non-fossil sources in proportion to the number of kilowatt hours they push into the power grid. No complicated rules, no governments speculating about which companies are going to succeed or fail, just this: you produce a KWh from solar/wind/hydro/whatever, you get a check. The end.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by msandford on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:23PM (#5796328)
And I wouldn't mind too much if what you're suggesting happened. But I've seen too much politics to bring myself to believe that it could get passed just like that, with no loopholes, pork, or other corruption.

You could structure it as a 95% of payments in go out to renewables producers. But the problem there is it doesn't provide any kind of stable payment structure for the renewables folks to structure their 10-50 year financing on.

If you set $x/kWh that's fine at first blush, but we could easily run into a situation with a big surplus (which goes into general coffers and is probably spent on wars) or a big deficit (which we definitely can't afford).

I like the idea but I can't see any way to implement it that doesn't end in tears in some way or another.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by darklight on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:18PM (#5796501)
The UK has been doing just this for the last three years: people get paid for all renewable KwH they generate - even those they use themselves. It's cut the ROI for renewables to 5-10 years in many cases - and 'free' energy and income thereafter. http://www.energysavingtrust.org.uk/Generating-energy/Gettin...
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:47PM (#5796410)
>But I've seen too much politics to bring myself to believe that it could get passed just like that, with no loopholes, pork, or other corruption.

There is a natural law that applies to politics as much as anything: If you think you can't do it, you don't try. And you can't do it if you don't try.

>You could structure it as a 95% of payments in go out to renewables producers. But the problem there is it doesn't provide any kind of stable payment structure for the renewables folks to structure their 10-50 year financing on.

I don't see how the volatility there would be any worse than the normal volatility in the energy market -- if anything it's a hedge against it because the primary method that could cause the subsidy to be reduced would be as a result of renewables rapidly supplanting fossil fuels, and in that scenario the renewables market is booming and the subsidy is less important.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by msandford on Saturday June 01, 2013 @08:46PM (#5806771)
>There is a natural law that applies to politics as much as anything: If you think you can't do it, you don't try. And you can't do it if you don't try.

I agree with this. It's absolutely true.

That said, I don't agree that government is necessarily the right place to "try" things as the nature of government is fundamentally VERY different than product design or other entrepreneurial endeavors. If you have a theory about how the business world should be and you fail, the company folds and it's undone. If a law is passed and it's imperfect, bad, or horrible we'll likely have to live with it forever or nearly so. The majority of the laws ever passed are still on the books today. The Patriot Act and the Brady Bill are the only two things I can think of that had an automatic expiration.

In other words, in markets there is virtually no hysteresis. When talking about conglomerates or other big, big businesses there is definitely some. When dealing with the law, hysteresis is the rule not the exception.

It is for that reason I find I am always hesitant to argue that we simply have to pass "A law stating X" and that we can fix things.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by duncan_bayne on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:28PM (#5796112)
That must be what optimism looks like.

You need to understand that many - a minority perhaps, but many - of the supporters of emission controls are opposed to industry per se, not the effects of same.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by guelo on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:37PM (#5796140)
And many - who knows what percentage - of deniers are motivated by hatred of liberals or environmentlists or Democrats or the UN or scientists. So what?
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by duncan_bayne on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:47PM (#5796179)
'Deniers' isn't a useful term - in fact, it's the kind of label that is designed to shut down debate. Like "communist" in the McCarthy era, or "defeatist" during WWI (hat tip to PG for opening my eyes to this).

Leaving that aside, my point to the OP was that he was being naive in assuming that calls to limit industry would cease if CFCs were proved to be the sole agent of AGW.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by mikeash on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:05PM (#5796262)
What term would you use? I can't think of one that's less loaded than "denier", which is at least fairly correct.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by duncan_bayne on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:09PM (#5796470)
I wouldn't use a term at all. There isn't a convenient description for a group of people whose opinions vary from "God promised he wouldn't drown the Earth, and that's why he creates rainbows" to "we think that CFC levels correlate better with climate data than CO2 levels".

Terms like "denier" or "warmist" are only useful if you want to shut down reasoned debate.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by mikeash on Friday May 31, 2013 @11:54AM (#5799324)
I don't know that their opinions are as varied as all that. Certainly they express that full range, but in my experience, they're all just contrarians of one stripe or another at heart, with the "God" or "CFC" stuff being rationalizations that stem from a belief that climate change is false, rather than the other way around.

If there were substantial numbers of people going from evidence to the conclusion that climate change is not real, then I could see not labeling them all with the same term, but there isn't.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by waterlesscloud on Friday May 31, 2013 @02:23AM (#5797200)
Of all the things about the climate debate, the use of "denier" is the one I despise the most.

It's very clearly meant to be pejorative and to up the political rhetoric level. It's taken directly from "holocaust deniers", and that's a shameful association to be making.

I can't take anyone who uses the term seriously on the issue, it's just too much of political hack word.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by ams6110 on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:31PM (#5796356)
skeptic
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by mikeash on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:54PM (#5796426)
I thought of that, but it seems to have far too many sarcastic overtones.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by Lagged2Death on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:19PM (#5796318)
I was under the impression that, since there hasn't been any recent evidence of warming, everybody had just substituted the more general term "climate change"...

Addresses a couple of your impressions rather directly:

http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2013/04/23/1909881/debunkin...

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by HEYGRANDMA on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:01PM (#5796244)
It's been called climate change for quite some time; for instance the IPCC was established in 1988: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ipcc
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by guelo on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:50PM (#5796196)
That Fox News myth has been debunked http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2013/04/23/1909881/debunkin...

But like a lot of propaganda it continues being spread after being killed. Zombie propaganda.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:02PM (#5796250)
I'm not quite sure what point the article was trying to make. It simply read like an unnecessarily rude and polarizing circle jerk. One one had, the author vaguely hints towards some sort of conspiracy only to offer one of his own (Frank Luntz and his back-room terminology redefining). Pure crap.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by breadbox on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:58PM (#5796232)
"I'm really crossing my fingers that preventing anthropogenic global warming is as simple as banning CFCs."

The snarky response of What's the weather like on your planet? has never seemed more appropriate.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by andyl on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:35PM (#5796135)
Yeah, what about the so-called 'global warming'?? We need to protect that oil and gas industry at all costs.

BTW, I heard that evolution is just a 'theory', and many experts seriously doubt that it can be true.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:38PM (#5796148)
We know much less about the climate than we do about evolution.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by jlgreco on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:50PM (#5796200)
You could say that of very many things... perhaps even most things. The body of research we have on evolution is awe inspiring.
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by andyl on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:49PM (#5796188)
Yeah - it's all just so mysterious and uncertain. 97% of climate scientists might say that human produced carbon causes warming. (http://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus) But that's just their opinion. There is still doubt. The imperative is to protect the oil and gas industry, and keep putting carbon into the atmosphere. It's great for the economy, and some say it's good for plants!
Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by baddox on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:04PM (#5796256)
Consensus is not science. 97% of "biologists" in the 17th century might have said that acquired traits are heritable, or perhaps that there is no common ancestry among species, but that is scientifically false now and was scientifically false then (barring for the moment epigenetics and neo-Lamarckism). Of course, without the luxury of hindsight, you can't really be sure yourself unless you are more confident in your scientific abilities than the so-called experts at the time or are able to personally recreate experiments and observe contradictory results (which is unlikely for things like speciation and climate change).

Note that I'm not saying I believe any specific theories are correct or incorrect. I'm just trying to make a general statement that appeals to consensus are themselves not that useful and are certainly not "science." Also note that I am well aware that opposing political groups might purposefully publicize articles disagreeing with the consensus in order to make it seem like there is less of a consensus than there actually is.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @08:56PM (#5796225)
"Consensus" is not a valid scientific argument. For the longest time it was the "consensus" that the earth was flat and that existence was only 6000 years old (although not if you ask early Catholic theologians - they always saw Genesis in a metaphoric light, but I digress).

Between this and your last comment, your "scientific" arguments aren't very persuasive, they sound more like daily kos talking points.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by lobster_johnson on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:42PM (#5796390)
No, that was never the concensus among scientists.

Scientific consensus is a valid argument in the same sense that "extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof"; the probability that mainstream science is wrong and you are right is low, proportionally to the amount of science at either end.

The fact that the Earth is round was known by the Greeks and has been acknowledged ever since, not least following several circumnavigations by people such as Magellan. The notion that people (scientists and laymen alike) believed in a flat earth is really a popular myth perpetrated, probably, to make the Columbus story more interesting. Columbus knew perfectly well that the Earth was round.

The fact that Earth and the universe are very old was pretty much agreed upon since the 18th century with the arrival of geology as a branch of science. Aristotle thought the universe was infinite in age. The Hindus thought it was billions of years old. The 6000 year thing is a very recent Christian idea.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @10:03PM (#5796450)
>Aristotle thought the universe was infinite in age

If we're going to nit-pick, this was the scientific "consensus" until a Catholic priest postulated the big bang.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by lobster_johnson on Friday May 31, 2013 @01:26PM (#5799914)
Considering that there are indications that black holes contain universes, implying that "big bangs" happen more than once, Aristotle's idea may not be wrong.

[1] http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/04/100409-black...

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by dragonwriter on Thursday May 30, 2013 @11:07PM (#5796617)
> For the longest time it was the "consensus" that the earth was flat and that existence was only 6000 years old

Actually, the educated (still pre-scientific, as the scientific method wasn't really established as a thing) consensus had turned against the former before the latter was even a thing, much less a consensus (which it never really was, either the first time, ~AD 500 with biblically-based -- from the Septuagint -- estimates of the date of creation ~5500 BC, or the second time ~AD 2000 with biblically-based -- from the Masoretic texr -- estimates of the date of creation ~4000 BC.)

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by mikeash on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:07PM (#5796273)
When was it the "consensus" that the Earth was flat? As far as I understand it, the Earth has been known to be round for approximately as long as people both thought to ask the question and attempt to figure out an answer.

"Consensus" may not give us proof, but in the absence of compelling evidence against it, it's fairly strong.

Yep, they could be wrong. But it's not the way to bet.

Re:Global warming caused by chlorofluorocarbons, not carbon ... by pvnick on Thursday May 30, 2013 @09:16PM (#5796302)
>When was it the "consensus" that the Earth was flat?

I don't know man I just threw that down as a hypothetical. Look at the sibling comment next to mine for a more well-thought-out refutation :)