I'm confident in my ability to say 'no' to an advertiser, just as I appreciate being told about things that might help my lifestyle. I'll research it, I'll look at the pros and cons as well as the costs and will make the final decision.
Although, fair disclosure, I run an ad blocker in my browser, so I don't see most of the ads anyway ;)
PleaseRobMe was a fun little project that those with a heightened concern for privacy love to point to, but I doubt it ever led to anyone having their house robbed. Again, the benefits of me being able to selectively tweet a conference hashtag and see if anyone wants to hang out in person outweighs the fear that someone's going to see if I left any Apple gadgets at home to steal.
Corporations get hacked in to and have data stolen from them all the time (the frequent news stories we hear about data breaches are probably just a drop in the bucket compared to those that happen and go unreported).
Unscrupulous employees of these corporations could use the data the corporation collects. This information could also be sold (either legitimately or illegitimately) to others. It could be for stalking, harassment, identity theft, finding out your political sympathies, sexual orientation, etc.
The data collected on you could be used by prospective employers, insurance agencies, or love interests to weed you out based on the impression (accurate or not) that they get of you or your social media "friends".
Once the data is collected, it could stick around virtually forever. And good luck correcting any mistakes in it.
Why not? How would you be in any way worse off because an advertiser knows this?
You might not post private information to Facebook but when and how often you post can tell someone more than you would casually share with a stranger like what your sleeping habits are or if you are at a special event (determined by the lack of generated events during a normally scheduled period of activity for you). After a while, even the non-interactions with the site can tell the site and their advertisers more about you than you might prefer.
Think of twitter bots like the automated RobMeNow tweets. Sure letting people know that you are buying a subway sandwich is mundane and hardly private information but entering that information into an archive that can be analyzed to determine how much you spend on fast food and when you are most likely to purchase fast food is probably not something you want to share with advertisers.
EDIT: People are commenting about how it's not so bad that advertisers know this information about you. I just want to add that you can replace "advertisers" with any noun that is legally or commercially entitled to the data. It could be a government or the company that acquires your social network.