I agree the example in the piece is a bit extreme, but was just trying to make a point. It is very possible to have a provocative thumbnail that is relevant to your video. I definitely don't advocate deceiving your audience.
Re:How to Make a Viral Video
by will_brown on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @10:12PM
(#5790476)
In fairness the example was followed up with:
"Maybe you don’t need to be this extreme, but your thumbnail should be interesting..."
I do agree with about everything else in the article, it is just the reinforcement of behavior that is a personal pet peeve of mine got a knee jerk reaction. I think "thumbnail fixing" is the 3rd largest problem on Video Sharing websites behind Youtube's comment threads (#2, I had to squeeze that pet peeve in).
Now, when it comes to a provocative thumbnail that is relevant to the video...great advice.
Edit: By "I agree" I mean I feel comfortable taking your advice. Good read.
Don't forget the youtube has an option to flag videos for misleading thumbnails.
Re:How to Make a Viral Video
by ryanholiday on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:54PM
(#5790823)
This is known as "thumbnail cheating"
"Make sure to give your video a provocative thumbnail. For example, this video (which got over 13 million views) used a thumbnail that was not really even related to the video itself."
It is crazy they openly encourage the community to do the same. It is the same as posting a provocative HN title unrelated to the post, creativity should be encouraged but not to the detriment of the community.