Re:A new Gmail inbox
by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:48PM
(#5788966)
> So you think that it's worse than min(idea, execution)?
Generally, yes, or at least "not better and usually worse."
But I said "more like idea * execution" -- compared to min(idea, execution) -- and the "more like" is important. Its not a strict mathematical relationship, and sometimes an imperfect implementation of an imperfect concept will end up better than either the implementation or the concept because it will be equivalent to a better implementation of a better concept by accident. But that's kind of exceptional case.
Generally, yes, or at least "not better and usually worse."
But I said "more like idea * execution" -- compared to min(idea, execution) -- and the "more like" is important. Its not a strict mathematical relationship, and sometimes an imperfect implementation of an imperfect concept will end up better than either the implementation or the concept because it will be equivalent to a better implementation of a better concept by accident. But that's kind of exceptional case.