News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Challenge HN: Break my in-browser crypto for $1000 by tptacek on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:23PM (#5788033)
Imagine if people built bridges the way you propose building secure software. "What do you think of someone who publicly calls a new bridge design unsafe, and then reacts with snark and doesn't actually attempt to destroy the bridge when the opportunity is put before her by someone willing to bend over backwards to help her do it?"

Engineering doesn't work that way. Your proposed solution doesn't become more sound simply because you feel aggrieved at the way people react to it.

Also: it's deeply dishonest to suggest that the only reaction you've received to this design is "snark". As I pointed out above, with a link and everything, and as you yourself acknowledged in your original post, you've been given a litany of reasons why your proposed design is flawed. You just don't seem to like hearing them.

Re:Challenge HN: Break my in-browser crypto for $1000 by absherwin on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:44PM (#5788194)
I'd expect them to propose a scenario that could be tested either with software or a miniature. You're under no obligation to but examples are persuasive. Feynman's ice water demonstration convinced far more people than his well-reasoned appendix.

I'm attempting to give those who believe that JS crypto should never be used a way to make a clear public demonstration. What better target could you ask for? A web application hacked together in a few hours by someone with no training in computer security who isn't even a professional software engineer and who is willing to arrange scenarios favorable to the attacker.

I'm not aggrieved by the negative reaction. I have no skin in this game. I don't earn anything if people walk away believing this idea is more secure. I just wish you wouldn't keep repeating the same canard about having to bootstrap the crypto on every use while attacking the messenger and the manner in which the message is being delivered.

Re:Challenge HN: Break my in-browser crypto for $1000 by chetanahuja on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:44PM (#5788192)
I'm inclined to agree with the original poster. If it's really as deeply insecure as you claim it is, you should be able to crack it in less than the 3 hours of time (that you also claim the proposed prize is worth). The OP even offered to increased the prize money if you think it'll take longer than that.

In other words, sometimes, you have to put your money where your mouth is. The OP is doing that. You're not.

Re:Challenge HN: Break my in-browser crypto for $1000 by cheesypotato on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:36PM (#5788132)
If it's actually _as_ insecure as you say, why not collect your $1000? You'd make it back even more with gained reputation of your status as a security expert.

Instead, I'm inclined to believe you just can't.