Re:Challenge HN: Break my in-browser crypto for $1000
by absherwin on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:06PM
(#5787922)
I'm uncomfortable with arguments that are equivalent to PerceivedBenefit(X)>RealBenefit(X) and RealBenefit(X)>0 but NegativeBenefit(Actions|PerceivedBenefit(X))>RealBenefit(X) so X should be banned.
Since PerceivedBenefit(X) and Actions will both vary by individual and are controllable through learning and discipline, I'd rather give individuals the right to choose.
Equivalent examples: Seatbelts are bad since people will drive recklessly; calculators are bad since people won't bother learning arithmetic; cars are bad since people will walk less. In each case, the negative does occur. I'd argue that as a whole society is better for all of those.
Since PerceivedBenefit(X) and Actions will both vary by individual and are controllable through learning and discipline, I'd rather give individuals the right to choose.
Equivalent examples: Seatbelts are bad since people will drive recklessly; calculators are bad since people won't bother learning arithmetic; cars are bad since people will walk less. In each case, the negative does occur. I'd argue that as a whole society is better for all of those.