News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by adventured on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:39PM (#5787344)
So they're giving me sub folders ("tabs") for my inbox folder. How very 1999.

What Gmail is really doing is adding more layers of complexity. Now they have hard wired folders (inbox, sent, etc), labels (aka custom folders), tabs in the inbox, and importance markers (starred / not).

They're making the same mistake that consumed many of Microsoft's email efforts: adding complexity thinking that's how you add 'power controls' and make it easier to sort mail.

Re:A new Gmail inbox by alooPotato on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:21PM (#5787649)
I think the key here is not the tabs, its the fact that they know which emails belong in which tabs. Auto labeling. I don't think its hard to imagine that this just get better over time such that our current way of doing this (setting up filters) becomes obsolete.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by typpo on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:51PM (#5787441)
I would think this simplifies email organization for the average user. Normal people don't use labels extensively and don't customize their inbox. With sane presets for these tabs, Google can give most users an inbox that is organized by default.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by russgray on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:04PM (#5787532)
I thought the point of gmail was that you didn't need to organize. Just search.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by vidarh on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:23PM (#5787665)
The Gmail search is beyond useless to me... Because I have too much stuff saved, and contrary to the web where pagerank provides a good signal, they don't have the same signal for search.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by shalstvedt on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:45PM (#5789369)
Indeed, that's the purported utility of Gmail: keep around every piece of information, so you never lose track of anything.

Does it work that well for you? How much email do you get on a daily basis?

(I work at a small software startup, SolNovus, that has been exploring this for a while, and for us, it doesn't seem to work that well in practice. Users can't always remember keywords for long-archived messages and have to resort to scanning pages of emails, even when tagged.)

Really, I think the ticket to having an inbox you don't have to organize is not to hide everything beneath the search box, however smart it may be. At some level, you need to incrementally generate queries, because the search will be imperfect. Things like search visualization methods that help incrementally refine queries, tied to more flexible and configurable machine learning, look promising.

Re:A new Gmail inbox by russgray on Thursday May 30, 2013 @06:05AM (#5791659)
I dunno, less than many people I suspect. 100 or so per day (not counting spam)? Search works well enough for me at the moment, though I do confess to tagging things like order confirmations and shipping notifications.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by aiiane on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:15PM (#5787614)
For email you've already read, sure. But it's often nice to have some organization for what you haven't yet read, so you can focus on the email you care most about first.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by dirkgently on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:14PM (#5787975)
> So they're giving me sub folders ("tabs") for my inbox folder. How very 1999.

And this is why /r/technology is going downhill.

OH, wait a minute! Never mind..

Re:A new Gmail inbox by aiiane on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:48PM (#5787409)
not forced to use it. What would you rather they add?
Re:A new Gmail inbox by adventured on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:56PM (#5787471)
Who said I want them to 'add' anything?

They can make it possible for me to easily search a trillion pages online from one input box, with a great hit ratio for what I'm actually looking for. But they need to add comical layers of complexity - none of which is new or unique - just to sort my email? It's depressing if that's the best their Gmail team can do.

These 'features' have been done before by other companies and other services, and they didn't solve the sorting problem of email. They're just repeating mistakes other companies made many years ago. There's nothing special about sub folders for an inbox folder, even if you call it a tab.

I would argue that Google needs to think originally again about email, as they did when they first came up with Gmail, and not repeat the poor product choices made by other email products and services.

Re:A new Gmail inbox by hnriot on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:03PM (#5787524)
the same old whining. If you don't like the new features, the blog clearly says you can choose not to use them, they provide backward compatibility.

You say this has been done before, what hasn't. You should live with the features for a while before jumping to immediately trashing them without even having used them.

Nothing is "new or unique" - and nobody wants that either. They want steady improvements without losing familiarity.

Re:A new Gmail inbox by dannyr on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:14PM (#5787603)
Dude, he's clearly whining without bothering to even read the post.

If he actually read it, no reason to complain because you can turn it off.

Re:A new Gmail inbox by jamoes on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:47PM (#5787815)
> because you can turn it off

I think the fear is that eventually they won't let you turn it off. Google has a habit of doing this type of thing with Gmail (eg the new UI, and the new compose)

Re:A new Gmail inbox by dannyr on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:57PM (#5788306)
then whine when it actually happens.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by aiiane on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:05PM (#5787537)
So basically you have no real constructive suggestions and are just instinctively lashing out at anything that doesn't feel "new". Gotcha.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by dmlorenzetti on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:31PM (#5787718)
How about useful search?

Currently, you can't direct searches within nested folders. You either search all messages, or search within one folder/label. So for example, I have e-mails grouped by project, and within big projects there are sub-labels:

  project1/testing
  project1/doc
  project1/proposals
  ...
  project2/testing
  ...
If I search in "project1", it doesn't look in any of those sub-folders.

Search also could use a grep-like capability. The "advanced search" options are a bit of a joke, especially coming from a company that cut its teeth on search.

Re:A new Gmail inbox by tuxracer on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:04PM (#5788734)
You can search nested labels. If you go into a sub label you should see the search box auto-populate with that label (including the nested on).

For example I have a nested label "Invites" in the label "Calendar" (Calendar/Invites). Searching "label:calendar-invites blah" searches for "blah" inside the nested label.

Re:A new Gmail inbox by khalstvedt on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:22PM (#5789197)
I agree, you can construct a pretty flexible search system with the existing Gmail implementation. (disclosure: I work at a small startup trying to address email search and archive organization). How many rules do you have set up to achieve your (arguably very reasonable) workflow?

However, to perform a successful search with specific constraints, you must either:

1) Remember a keyword

2) Have a label for the particular constraint you want to use

Our little startup, SolNovus (http://solnovus.com), has been investigating how to make a couple power-user functions like this more accessible. Our priorities are:

1) Fuzzy topic search: make keywords more forgiving

2) Analysis and visualization of email graph: sift through related threads and see the impact of search constraints, represent scale and organization with more than an inbox counter

Re:A new Gmail inbox by dmlorenzetti on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:54PM (#5789425)
I know you can search within Calendar/Invites.

The issue arises if you know the message you want is somewhere under Calendar, but you're not sure whether it's in Calendar/Invites or Calendar/Rejected or Calendar/DateNotSetYet. As far as I know, it's not possible to search them all at once, just by searching under the tag Calendar.

Re:A new Gmail inbox by jamoes on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:44PM (#5787799)
How about built-in PGP? Even if google stored the private keys by default, it would be a huge step in the direction of getting people to actually use PGP and care about the privacy of their communication.
Re:A new Gmail inbox by betterunix on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:54PM (#5788682)
"What would you rather they add?"

Sieve support. Why do I need to log into their website (i.e. why do I need to log in a second time, when I already logged in via my mail client) just to set up a server-side filter?