News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California’s proposed "Amazon tax" - a destructive solution by gojomo on Saturday April 25, 2009 @01:15AM (#578647)
It only makes outside companies a California taxpayer upon sales into California. That doesn't have to be confusing; it just makes cross-state sales more like in-state sales. In state retail sales were, for a century-plus, the norm. It's the special exemption for cross-state sales that has been arbitraged by online retailers. I don't blame them but it's not socially optimal.

I wish the 9th and 10th amendments were relevant; they were effectively nullified by the courts and congress long ago.

The problem is an unforeseen development -- massive cross-border retailing -- has created revenue holes for states and distorted incentives for consumers and businesses, advantaging out-of-state retailers and long shipments over local businesses. It's hard for individual states to fix, because there's an incentive for some states to defect, become islands of online/catalog retailers, and use the tax discontinuity to gain jobs by legal arbitrage -- not any true business-friendliness. (It's a bit like the competition for sports stadiums in that dimension -- it'd better if no jurisdictions offered giant subsidies, but once the bidding starts, it's hard not to match others' offers.)

Congress could solve using its power to regulate interstate congress; otherwise inefficiencies and unproductive gaming between the states will continue.

There are no comments on this comment yet.