Re:Doctor stops accepting insurance, posts prices online
by johnsoft on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:02AM
(#5785044)
I've always wondered, why do people use this argument for medical care, but not food? Both are necessary to carry on living, and both are provided by people who themselves work full-time and need to keep the lights on somehow.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Doctor stops accepting insurance, posts prices online
by jackowayed on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:35AM
(#5785125)
The cost of food is very predictable and pretty flexible. Anyone who needs to can eat well on <$100/week as long as they have access to a reasonably-priced grocery store and facilities to cook and store food. (Also, note that even our barebones welfare state includes foodstamps.)
On the other hand, medical costs can vary wildly and randomly. A perfectly healthy person who's been following health best practices might suddenly develop a serious condition that is treatable, but only with five to six figures of treatment.
Re:Doctor stops accepting insurance, posts prices online
by kefka on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:13AM
(#5785353)
Foodstamps, for a single white male, is $207 a month in Indiana.
And 3 months ago, I was cut. Paperwork's "lost in the system". No job. No unemployment. Living on the scraps of money I had in goods that I sold.
Re:Doctor stops accepting insurance, posts prices online
by laumars on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:36AM
(#5785267)
There are allowances for food. That's what government schemes like income support is for. That's what state pensions are for. They're there to cover the bare essentials (food, water, heating and -to a lesser degree- rent).
The problem is such schemes are abused by many individuals where parents refuse to work because they'd "earn" more money from income support and such like. Those that know how to work the system to afford luxuries instead of the money going to towards the essentials to survive. But that's a whole other topic.
Re:Doctor stops accepting insurance, posts prices online
by vidarh on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:27AM
(#5785242)
Are people not using this argument for food? Almost every developed country have substantial social welfare programs to ensure that everyone can get access to food and housing.
Re:Doctor stops accepting insurance, posts prices online
by ollysb on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:19AM
(#5785094)
While there may be much debate regarding who should receive them I don't think anyone in the UK is arguing that we should get rid of social benefits.
Re:Doctor stops accepting insurance, posts prices online
by tlrobinson on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:15AM
(#5785088)
Exactly. Your country has just chosen to draw the line at a slightly different point.
Re:Doctor stops accepting insurance, posts prices online
by munimkazia on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @04:12AM
(#5785207)
I am just guessing here.. but it is much harder to manage because it would be a nightmare to distribute food for every single meal, every single day to all those who need it. Medical care is different. Most people don't have to walk into a hospital three times a day to get their daily care (hopefully)