News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My takeaways from "Clean Code" by jcampbell1 on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:06PM (#5783973)
I just find that minimizing parameters makes a mess with tons of side effects. When I see nothing but 0 and 1 parameter functions, the code is typically doing the logical equivalent of refactoring `add(a,b);` into `push(a);push(b);add();` which makes a mess when there is more than the trivial case.

jQuery.ajax is a 33 parameter function. No one complains, and it is nice that it doesn't have side effects.

Re:My takeaways from "Clean Code" by jacques_chester on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:14PM (#5783999)
Sure. Usually when you find a strict rule, it's a rule to be considered ceteris paribus -- when all other things are fixed in place. So while thinking about parameters, I think about minimising them and ignore other considerations. When thinking about side-effects, I think about minimising them and ignore other considerations.

It's when the rules conflict that mere rule-following ends and professional judgement begins.

Basically, as noted legal scholar Captain Barbossa observed, they're less like laws and more like guidelines.