News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by kyllo on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @08:07PM (#5783707)
I noticed that devs on HN often sneer at CRUD apps because they're boring to build, but meanwhile a simple CRUD app could do something like make all these veterans' medical benefit claims paperless so that they can get filled out and approved in minutes rather than months, and they could get the care they need sooner. One could do a lot of good by just making CRUD apps for people who need them and can't afford to pay much for them.
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by mikeash on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @08:13PM (#5783739)
All the technology in the world won't make those veterans' benefit claims go through any faster. The problem there isn't the technology (it's not all that hard of a problem) but getting it into the right place, past all the gatekeepers who want to keep it out.

It's not that nobody is building the technology because they're concentrating on other things, but rather nobody is building it because they know it won't sell, because it would have to go sixteen thousand layers of red tape and many tours through Congress before anything got done.

I think there's probably a lot of scope for solving problems with fairly simple apps, but this example seems like a terrible one.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by vkou on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:08PM (#5783979)
From what I understand of Veteran's Affairs, the technology has been built, and it does sell. The only problem is that the government's being fleeced for all its got by the vendors in question.

VA's got no end of computer systems, where its staff hand-enter information in one system, print out its report, only to scan it, fax it across the country, where someone else will hand-enter it into... A different system.

Engineers, consultants, and Serious Business Contracts were involved in the construction of this abomination - and while they were all in compliance of the standards that the government expects from its vendors, none of them delivered a good product.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by jlujan on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:20AM (#5786754)
"On February 5, 2013, the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Veterans Affairs announced that instead of building a single integrated electronic health record (iEHR), both DOD and VA will concentrate on integrating VA and DOD health data by focusing on interoperability and using existing technological solutions. This announcement was a departure from the previous commitments that both Departments had made to design and build a new single iEHR, rather than upgrading their current electronic health records and trying to develop interoperability solutions."

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R42970.pdf

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by kyllo on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @03:43PM (#5788605)
Gee, that doesn't sound expensive at all.
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by kyllo on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:32AM (#5784780)
Do they not even use EDI to communicate between the systems?
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by kyllo on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:23AM (#5784746)
You're right, you're right. The VA thing is a bad example. Enterprise software is expensive because big companies make themselves expensive to sell to. And the government is the biggest company of all. I'm sure they spend seven to eight figures on the cruddiest of CRUD apps from companies like Oracle.

On the other hand, something like a basic CRUD app could really help out a charity or non-profit that serves disadvantaged populations, and that could be built in Rails or Django for just a few days of developer time.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by walshemj on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:23PM (#5787661)
Not so sure abotu the charity market. one example back in 2000 I worked on a cheap and cheerful Paperless direct debit so that any Charity could quickly and easily set up a system to take donations.

The trouble was each flipping charity/bank wanted a bespoke version some of the changes required by the banks where absoluty nit picking.

The product had some good press for the Minister but could we get charity's/banks to hold their nose and just use one form! NO

Wonder if any VC in old street/silicon roundabout want to try again I still have few contacts form my days at Poptel

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by scrumper on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @08:48PM (#5783897)
Maybe that's the problem to solve then: navigating (or, dare I say it, disrupting) government procurement.
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by kylebgorman on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:13PM (#5783998)
A procurement reform program was Philadelphia's submission to the "Mayors Challenge" this year (http://mayorschallenge.bloomberg.org/index.cfm?objectid=184A...). It lost out to Providence, RI's proposal (I have argued elsewhere that Providence's proposal, while noble, is probably a boondoggle: http://wellformedness.com/blog/on-the-providence-word-gap-in...)
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by mnutt on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:00PM (#5783953)
That reminds me of DonorsChoose, which connects elementary teachers with people looking to donate. It's unfortunate that many states don't properly fund things like school supplies, but it's a great service nonetheless.
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by Crake on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @01:49AM (#5784819)
Plus the people who do the paper apps processing probably don't want to have their jobs eliminated and have an interest in refusing new (if computers can be considered "new") technology. Even if it means letting vets die due to the needlessly extended waiting process.
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by arkades on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @08:16PM (#5783752)
The VA has the largest, best-maintained electronic medical records system in the country. It is open-source and available to the public.

The problem with vets is not the absence of software. I am rather tired of seeing this particular horse beaten.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by Cyranix on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:09PM (#5783981)
Can you take this comment a step further and attempt an explanation for why a gargantuan pile of paperwork does exist despite such excellent software?
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by dr_ on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:55PM (#5784129)
Yes, part of it is registering vets into the system. The other part is a combination of the enormous number of claims and enormous amount of documentation required. As a physician, I worked in C&P (compensation and pension) clinics for a number of years at the VA, as a consultant. The amount of documentation required is astronomical, likely because vets are being compensated for their injuries with taxpayer dollars. Fair enough, but a physician providing these services could find other ways to use their time productively (for themselves). Then there's the volume. You don't just see vets who have lost an arm or a leg or have suffered traumatic brain or spinal cord injuries. You also see the guys who may have sprained a knee or ankle playing basketball in their free time but while they were officially on duty. Throw that into the mix, and you have too many people to examine so thoroughly. They tried to fix this by contracting with an agency and have vets come into a private medical office instead of doctors going to the VA, my partner did this for a while, but the reimbursement offered for the amount of paperwork required ultimately made it impractical. To fix it: 1) screen vets better, some are clearly more severely injured than others 2) better compensate providers who see all these vets and complete all the necessary documentation.

The screening part is tricky though, as it can quickly get political.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by dsuth on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @11:15PM (#5784354)
Another possibility would be to not screen them, provide them with a high level of free care as a reward for their service, and just make the system work efficiently. Whether the government is footing the bill, or an individual is, should make no difference at all to the timeliness or level of care they receive. If the problem is paperwork, that should be targeted first.
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by rdl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:38PM (#5789309)
There is a lot of medical care available (I think "stay on Tricare", etc.) with less hassle. Most of the disability claims are for ongoing cash payments to replace job income, which is more at risk of fraud (and in some cases genuinely uncertain and requiring investigation).
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by arkades on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @10:01PM (#5784150)
In part the problem arises from the interface between systems. If you walk into any normal hospital internal medicine floor you'll see about 5 different systems in use, with varying levels of interoperability: the VA, operating what is the largest network of healthcare centers in the country, takes that issue to the next order of magnitude. A lot of paper gets generated at these interfaces. Although the core VA EMR system is solid, there are multiple other systems laid atop it. The VA is attempting to address both the software and processes issue (people outside healthcare don't know this, but the VA is the place to take your career if you wish to do healthcare services research - they're, collectively, the single most innovative group of providers in the country).

The main problem lies with the paper backlog of attempting to get people into the system. I'm personally not aware of how/why military personnel's medical records don't transition directly into the VA, but what happens in practice is a gap between military med. and the VA, where vets find themselves forced to file claims. I suspect that this is in large part because the set of "Vets" and the set of people qualifying for VA care, while overlapping, are not the same (that assertion comes from anecdote: I had an ex in the military, and when she finished her tours I recall that she was not qualifying for VA care because she hadn't been disabled nor gone career, as she explained it). While it's fair to ask why this process is done on paper, it's worth-while to note that prior to just the last handful of years the portion of health records that had been digitized was nearly nil (up until about 5 years ago it was standard practice in most hospitals and private clinics to go digital-to-paper-to-digital). Essentially everyone's records were on paper, and all record transfers happened via fax (and still do, if a receiving physician is not inside the same hospital system on the same EMR as the referring physician).

source: work in hospital QI. I haven't worked in the VA, personally, so I am relating a lot of stuff second-hand, but the boundary between most hospitals' QI staff, the IHI, and the VA tends to be pretty porous, if you're in a healthcare capitol city - so I've heard a lot about the VA from co-workers that have worked there, or are currently engaged in ops research there.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by rdl on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @05:42PM (#5789352)
The problem is on the medical records DOD uses AHLTA and the quality of records in AHLTA is highly variable. They focus much more on proving immediate care vs. great quality records, both due to the environment where a lot of the care happens and because they're not billing for it.

There are also about 5 levels of bureaucracy to manage a single system within DOD. VA is amazing in comparison (it was really telling talking to doctors who had civilian jobs in the VA but were military reservists and working temporarily in military hospitals...)

Medical records aren't sufficient to make a determination of disability, though, which is mainly what this is about. Having the medical records helps, having personnel records helps.

Another problem is the VA for a long time was focused on long-term care for WW2/Korea elderly vets, and various mentally/physically disabled Vietnam vets. The population of seriously injured younger vets (who could still work, and have long and otherwise productive lives ahead of them, but need specific disability care) is a pretty new thing. That, and the huge number of PTSD/TBI/psych issues.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by jlujan on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:24AM (#5786777)
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by zdw on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @09:42PM (#5784092)
I'm going to guess that they're two separate things.

Medical records keeps track of medical procedure, patient history, what medications they're on, etc. In the private sphere, this is what a hospital would use.

What's probably at cause for the huge backlog is actually getting people into the system and approved for care. In the private sphere, this is what an insurance company would use.

Or this could be just your standard set of political exaggerations.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by adamgravitis on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:42AM (#5786889)
I think I've noticed a pattern with these kinds of systems: its not a software problem; it's a policy problem.

When designing (evolving, inventing) rules, regulations, policy, exceptions, limitations, audits, checks, balances, the bureaucracy's princes seem to ignore the bigger picture of what it's all become: a mess.

It's not just government systems either. There's a reason why people joke about their phone bills being difficult to understand. Same goes for most utilities.

Now, once you have an incoherent, contradictory, thousand page mishmash set of rules, every engineer worthy of the title is going to stay as far away as possible. So, the whole mess gets dumped on an army of coders from a big consultancy.

Perhaps instead of focusing on the useless software written to fit a pile of inane rules, people could focus on the economic and operational benefits of redoing the entire policy regime with a zen-shaped comb.

Software is an enabler. It's actually covered-up a lot of really awful decision-making. The US tax code could never have become what it is if developers hadn't been able to consistently keep up with crazy new patches to implement it: nobody could possibly manage it by hand.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by tel on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @11:56AM (#5786980)
As someone working on a healthcare startup, a thousand times this.

More than the technical disgust of building a policy-laden system, marketing is terrifically difficult under regulation. Consumers get scarred by inconsistent regulatory rules and stop being willing to change processes because it's too frightening to possibly run afoul of policy.

This is, by the way, a great opportunity for organizing regulatory consultants. Such a service might be an important forerunner or partner to ventures trying to change heavily regulated industries.

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by whiddershins on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @12:47AM (#5784646)
This and all the responses to it seem hopelessly naive to me. Obviously, if there is a delay in benefits, the delay has been introduced as a cost cutting measure. The more you delay, the less you pay. This is a pretty typical measure for large organizations trying to surreptitiously reduce costs (see welfare or HMOs) and the problem has nothing to do with logistics.
Re:The Unexotic Underclass by mynameishere on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @08:55PM (#5783933)
a simple CRUD app could do something like make all these veterans' medical benefit claims paperless

Changing a massive medical system from paper-based to digital is "simple"?

Re:The Unexotic Underclass by yardie on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:31AM (#5786135)
In a past life I built one of these CRUD apps. The CRUD part was simple. The volumes of rules and exceptions is where the time and money went. At one point I tried to replace a DOS terminal-based system with something that would resemble a GUI. Based off the old GUI it was easy to replicate, then the rulebooks came out and I realised I was way over my head.