Yes, I get that that's his point--but he's not just saying he wants to do that himself, he's saying he wants to influence other people to do it. He's convinced it's so important that it's OK to skew the information he gives people in order to influence them. At least, that's what I read between the lines. (And btw, I'm not saying this is what he intended; I'm just saying that's how it comes across to me.)
Btw, as I said to ableal, thanks for discussing instead of downvoting. :-)
In particular, anyone who designs a user interface – which guides you to do thing A rather than thing B – is in the persuasion game. They're trying to shape your behavior for - hopefully - your own good. Blackhat UX is when the converse happens.
Facts are the domain of pure math. Everything else is conditional.
Because it's extremely difficult to set out to persuade someone of something and not give them a skewed presentation of the issue about which you are trying to persuade them. (IMO it's actually impossible, but just "extremely difficult" is sufficient for this discussion.) And as soon as you skew your presentation of the issue, no matter how you rationalize it in terms of "it's for their own good" or "I've spent a lot of time and effort on this, I know more than they do", etc., etc., you're still, at the end of the day, substituting your judgment for theirs. IMO that's never a good thing.
"you know, this is a position of power, I have a responsibility to use it for good, as I see it"
Why is it a position of power? Who gave it to him? And why did he take it, instead of saying, "No, I'm not going to take this power and try to use it for good. That never works. Go look up the facts and make up your own mind."
Bottom line, I simply don't accept that it has to be that way--that somebody has to have power, and so the best we can do is hope they'll use it for good. I get that it's human nature to let things be that way, I get that the alternative--that everybody makes up their own mind, period, no exceptions--is scary to many people (not to mention that it would basically break our entire media culture). But that doesn't make it right.
anyone who designs a user interface – which guides you to do thing A rather than thing B – is in the persuasion game. They're trying to shape your behavior for - hopefully - your own good.
Again, I get that this point of view is rampant--it basically defines Apple, for example--but that doesn't make it right. (And yes, I know that Apple does this because its customers pay for it. That doesn't make it right either.)
Just to be clear, I'm not saying that I expect things to change any time soon. I labeled my OP as "ranting" for a reason. :-)
Facts are the domain of pure math. Everything else is conditional.
Really? Gravity is conditional? The way a microchip works is conditional? Or more to the point: is "anyone who designs a user interface is in the persuasion game" conditional? You didn't make it sound that way.
In particular, if I make up my own mind to consider another in a position of power, why is that "not right"?
It's "not right" in the sense that, by giving another person the power to decide what's "good" for you, you're giving up an important part of your human potential. As I said, I get that it's human nature to do this: evolution has hard-wired this behavior pattern into our brains. Most of our closest evolutionary relatives form dominance hierarchies, which is what "considering another in a position of power" means: you're putting them above you in the hierarchy.
But we humans have the ability to consider abstractions, like a concept of "good" over and above basic survival and subsistence, that other species do not. (At least, we have no evidence that they do, and considerable evidence that they do not.) But "good" is something somewhat different for each individual; no two people have exactly the same concept of "good" (though there is obviously a lot of overlap). If you let someone else decide what's "good" for you, you're giving up the part that's unique to you, because no one else can really know what that is. Only you can really figure out how best to use the unique combination of human qualities that you have, but to do that you have to decide for yourself what your "good" is; you have to refuse to put anyone else in a position of power.
Btw, this is, of course, not original with me, though I've put it in my own words above. It's the basic idea of the Enlightenment; it's the basic idea behind the Declaration of Independence ("life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" means not letting anyone else tell you what "happiness" means for you).
Only you can really figure out how best to use the unique combination of human qualities that you have
Do you have anything to back up this claim? It seems very wishy-washy.
which is what "considering another in a position of power" means: you're putting them above you in the hierarchy
This is a rather one-dimensional way of looking at the world. There are all sorts of power, and all sorts of ways one can hold another in power. There's nothing fundamentally wrong with the relationship between me and my local police officer. He is in a position of power, in that I've agreed to follow his directions in most cases, and it's a mutually beneficial relationship. There's also nothing wrong with the relationship between me and my Congressman. He's in a position of a power in that he creates (with others) the law of the land, and I am in a different position of power in that I vote him in or out. I can go on and on, as the world is full of complex relationships, but with respect to the subject at hand, you seem to be arguing that someone is wrong for considering a person worthy of giving advice, and putting that person in a "position of power" by allowing them to speak that advice. It seems really silly.
To the extent that there is a difference, yes, this is true. Eating sweets may be "right" for you or me, but not for someone who has diabetes. Learning computer programming may be "right" for you or me, but not for someone whose talents and interests make them much better suited to be a plumber.
But as I said, there is a lot of overlap, and where there is overlap, people share a concept of "right". There is pretty general agreement that it's "right" not to murder people, for example.
Do you have anything to back up this claim? It seems very wishy-washy.
It seems obvious to me. Nobody else shares your experience; nobody else lives life from your point of view.
There are all sorts of power, and all sorts of ways one can hold another in power.
True, but not all of them involve influence or advice. I don't ask my local cop for advice. I certainly don't ask my Congressman for advice, although lots of people do look to their Congressman for guidance on political issues (more on that below). The cop and the Congressman are basically my agents; I've contracted them (through a very convoluted process, true) to take care of certain things that we, as a society, have generally agreed need to be taken care of. That relationship does involve giving the cop and the Congressman certain powers, yes; and not all of them are good ideas, IMO. But it's not the kind of power you're talking about (or it shouldn't be--again, more on that below).
you seem to be arguing that someone is wrong for considering a person worthy of giving advice, and putting that person in a "position of power" by allowing them to speak that advice.
It depends on what you mean by "advice". There's advice, as in "tell me what you think" vs. advice as in "tell me what I should do". The former seems fine to me; you're just seeking information. The latter does not; you're asking someone else to make a decision that you should be making yourself.
There is an important special case, though, which I alluded to above. What about appointing a specialist, so to speak, as your agent in an area where they have special expertise? That's what the cop is, basically; and the same goes for doctors, lawyers, and other experts that we hire. The same is supposed to go for the Congressman too; they are supposed to be specialists in politics, in coming up with consensus solutions to difficult issues.
That was supposed to be how the US government worked: it was supposed to be a republic, where people elected representatives who were supposed to have better than average knowledge and judgment about politics. That means the representatives are not really giving advice or guidance; they're not telling you how to vote. They're just doing the job they were hired to do; and if you don't like the job they're doing, you vote them out.
But now every political issue has to be decided by popular consensus--not just consensus of the representatives, but consensus of all the people. And so now people look to their politicians to tell them what to think, instead of exercising their own independent judgment about how well their politicians are doing their jobs. In other words, the fact that people expect politicians to give "advice" and guidance is a sign that the system is broken.
The audience matters. ;-)
True, but not relevant to the argument I'm making. The fact that his attempt to influence people might well have more leverage because of his audience doesn't make influencing people, as opposed to informing them, any more right than it would otherwise be. In fact, it might make it even worse.
Look at it this way: his basic argument is that humanity's most valuable asset is ideas. The more good ideas we have, the better. And the best way to spread ideas is replication--people learn them from other people. So he's basically saying that influencing people is good because it helps to spread good ideas.
But here's the thing: in a sane society, good ideas don't need help to spread. They spread naturally, because people are not fools. If you have a good idea, use it. In this case, instead of telling people how important he thinks it is to develop good tools for thinking, he should just do it--develop tools for thinking that he thinks are good, and use them to do some superior thinking. If he's right, people will naturally adopt the tools because they can see that the tools work.
But when you add "influence" into the mix, you now have created a second way for ideas to spread, one that does not depend on whether or not they are actually good ideas. If people start thinking, hey, this guy is a mover and shaker, a "thought leader", someone I should listen to, they will spread his idea even if it's not a good idea. So influencing people, persuading people, in fact will have the opposite effect to the one he thinks: it's not needed to spread good ideas, but it can help to spread bad ideas that would otherwise die out. And if his audience contains people who are more likely to spread whatever ideas he persuades them to spread, the damage done by a bad idea is even greater.
Ideas do, in my experience, need help to spread. Particularly if they are unorthodox ideas. There's a resistance to ideas that live outside the box, they aren't automatically accepted by people just because they're good.
I work really hard at evaluating ideas that are new to me based on their merits. But it's sometimes extremely difficult to do. And,to be completely blunt, most people don't make the effort, even if they're otherwise intelligent.
In other words, you think that just your opinion that it's a good idea is sufficient to justify influencing others, even if you haven't actually tried it? You don't feel any obligation to test it yourself first, to see whether it's really a good idea or whether you were mistaken? How does that square with this:
I work really hard at evaluating ideas that are new to me based on their merits. But it's sometimes extremely difficult to do.
In other words, you admit it's very difficult to evaluate new ideas, but yet you think you're obligated to try to influence others to adopt them without having tried them yourself first? Wouldn't it be much more sensible to try the idea yourself first, since it's so difficult to evaluate it on its merits just by looking at it?
There's a resistance to ideas that live outside the box, they aren't automatically accepted by people just because they're good.
I do disagree with this as you state it, yes. I would say there is resistance to out of the box ideas that have not been demonstrated to work. And the way to overcome this resistance is to demonstrate that the idea works, instead of trumpeting how good it is before you've tested it yourself.
most people don't make the effort, even if they're otherwise intelligent.
Yes, that's true. And I would say it's because people's time and energy are limited, and they already have enough to do with it without adopting this new idea that you say is so great, but you have no evidence to back it up.
Edit: I should add that I put a key qualifier in my statement about good ideas spreading naturally: I said it happens that way in a sane society. I do not think we currently live in a sane society, and the reason why is that in our society, the second method of spreading ideas has crowded out the first one. People don't evaluate ideas based on whether they've been demonstrated to work; they evaluate them based on who is saying they're good ideas.
So there are actually two reasons why "there's a resistance to ideas that live outside the box"; in addition to the one I gave above (that there's a resistance to out of the box ideas that haven't been demonstrated to work), there is also a second reason: there's a resistance to ideas that are "out of the box" in the sense that they come from a source that isn't on the list of "approved" sources for ideas. The second reason could apply even to an idea that has been demonstrated to work. But even in that case, the reason for trying to get the idea adopted should still be "this idea has been demonstrated to work", not "I think this is a good idea, even though I'm not on your list of approved sources for ideas".
Well, no, I didn't say that.
A charitable interpretation of his meaning leads to the same conclusion you have. Maybe what he means is "Every talk is for an audience, and it's the speaker's responsibility to say what the audience needs to hear so they understand the point"?
100 years? How about 10 years? Our inability to predict the future works on much shorter timescales than he seems to think. Why the emphasis on 100 years?
Because he's referencing a talk given at the 100th anniversary of CalTech.
Other than that, yes, I agree, it did come off as a bit pretentious. But I feel his point, he wants to work on things that matter to him, for the time frame he defines.