This sort of thing is why I'm tired of political news on HN.
[1] http://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/eliminating-oil-...
[2] http://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/oil-subsidies-do...
Because someone interpreted information differently than you, or did not do the same research as you? I think you'll tire quickly of political discussion anywhere, in that case.
From my perspective, your reply to the parent's comment is exactly why HN works. Someone makes an assertion, and another person comes along and adds additional information to better round out the issue. (Thank you for that, btw.)
That's about as close as anyone has ever come to fully-backing oil subsidies. They're not terribly popular in normal political discourse. The piece unveils a dubious argument that evades the fact that taxes on oil are used to finance the cost of roads and highways. They do not serve to mitigate national defense costs, environmental damages, or health costs caused by burning fossil fuels, extracting them, or refining them. These costs are borne mostly as hidden externalities paid by government and consumers.
Also, claiming that "That's about as close as anyone has ever come to fully-backing oil subsidies" is quite laughable.
[2] clearly does not endorse subsidizing oil.
The issue here is not mere inconsistency.
The need for early subsidies to make early profits has little bearing on whether they are a boon or a drain. Whether the cars are expensive or not is even more irrelevant. When the subsidies wear off, it's very likely that Tesla will have economies of scale working and more mainstream models. The jobs and environmental benefits have real value that Cato is not factoring into their simplistic formula.
This can be disputed, of course, but as it stands it doesn't make much sense to point to such factors as missing, in my opinion.
One needs look no further than Cato's full-throated endorsement of oil subsidies[2]. Despite admitting externalities exist, they put their stamp of endorsement on oil industry subsidies while opposing far smaller industry-paid subsidies for Tesla, a company whose product harms profits of oil companies.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5753993 [2] http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/big-oil-pub...