Brad never ripped on anything else Tom has done. He never even suggested that the state of the god docs reflected poorly on him as a developer or a person. He was merely supplying information and venting frustration over the previous six months he spent attempting to get Tom's product to work properly. Hell, he wasn't even mad that it was (for him) an incomplete, non-functioning product, he was just upset that it wasn't presented as such!
I didn't know who Tom Preston-Werner was before this post, but apparently he has indeed bootstrapped several successful startups and is a great open source contributor. Good for him, and I thank him for his contributions. One of the reasons I want to become financially secure is so that I can devote most of my time to OSS, so everyone who contributes largely to said software gets my utmost respect and admiration. I don't see how any of that has any bearing on the status of god's documentation, however.
"call a turd a turd"
The guy sounds like an 8 year old. It's just incredibly unbecoming. Anyway, if you like his blog, good for you.
I like Brad as a person, but I don't think I've read his blog before. And he usually acts on par with an 11 year old, so take that into account.
To then sit around calling it names is an insult not just to Tom but to anyone who is engaged in productive, creative work. Also, this kind of thing will only discourage others from releasing their code to the community...
That's not a negative review, it's a slap in the face.
Also, it is somewhat disgusting to me that a wanna-be blogger would decide (to publicize his blog?) to rip on a guy who has been a great open source contributor AND has managed to bootstrap several successful startups (notably gravatar and github).
Tom is clearly busy and productive and is (in my opinion) a great role model for how to combine excellence in open source and entrepreneurship, and is the LAST person that anyone should be going out of their way to rip on.