You are right, ioquake3 is not a clone. It's still really prominent and I don't want to omit it.
As for OpenArena, this is more 'inspired by', since in my opinion 'clone' follows original game a bit closer. I agree that the difference can be subtle, but that's how I've chosen to treat those words. :)
Re:Open Source Game Clones
by willvarfar on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @03:11AM
(#5778632)
How about Megaglest? Very active development, very playable, lots of modders.
But it had no precursor. While the project certainly looks nice, it's outside of objectives of this site.
Edit: Hm, I'm sorry, original Glest is from 2004. Maybe I should include this in the end...
OpenTTD created their own assets a while ago so they can distribute the entire game libre, it is like UrbanTerror + ioquake3.
Re:Open Source Game Clones
by dietrichepp on Monday May 27, 2013 @06:25PM
(#5776932)
Except Urban Terror is not open source. You cannot get the source code anywhere. (It is gratis/無料 but not libre/自由.)
Why the japanese characters ? :) You could have use the free beer, free speech analogy :)
Re:Open Source Game Clones
by dietrichepp on Thursday May 30, 2013 @03:58PM
(#5794819)
They're Chinese characters, which are used to write the Japanese language. Just like we use Latin characters to write the English language.
Re:Open Source Game Clones
by twelvechairs on Monday May 27, 2013 @04:47PM
(#5776502)
Similarly, Abuse is not a 'clone' but was released into the public domain in its entirety and has had some work done to it since (cross platform porting, etc.)
Like the Ur-Quan Masters of Star Control 2. They only had to change the name for legal reasons.
Why wouldn't a forked distribution be considered a "clone"? If bio-clones start from the same DNA, distribution "clones" start from the same source code...
A reverse-engineered game might be better termed a "dopple-gamer", since if didn't start from identical source.
I think ioquake3 is an example of where open source game devs are at their best. Providing modern engines (ideally from the original source, but not necessarily) to old games so that people can continue to reasonably play them. OpenTTD would be another example.