Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary
by tolmasky on Monday May 27, 2013 @08:00PM
(#5777234)
Also, the population of the falklands is around 3000 total people. Even if it were an "occupation" (which I agree it is not since most people there identify as British), it would be like occupying a tiny village.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary
by bdunbar on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @02:34AM
(#5784956)
> The British forces did not "take and hold ground", the repelled an invasion force.
Incorrect. The Argentines surprised the small garrison, had the place in a few hours. The Brits then mobilized an amphibious force and had to take the Falklands back.
> did not hold any ground for a long period of time.
I don't recall there being a qualification for 'time spent on the ground'. And incorrect because we've had forces in Kuwait ever since.
Re:This Is What Winning Looks Like – Afghanistan War Diary
by lobster_johnson on Wednesday May 29, 2013 @09:45AM
(#5786203)
You're arguing semantics. In the Falklands, the ground was British in the first place, and the Argentinians did not occupy the entire island; they repelled an invasion force, and saying that "held ground" is like saying the US has "held ground" from the British since the Revolution. Similarly, Kuwait was friendly territory; I was referring to Iraq.
Desert Storm: The US did not hold any ground for a long period of time. They defeated the Iraqi forces and withdrew.