See here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement
The "cheating" accusation comes because you have to be very large to be able to make use of this. If everyone could use this tax arrangement people wouldn't complain. (Well, they would complain that it exists, but not that people use it.)
This is a relatively recent change to the Irish tax code (based on the pace of tax law development)--and was introduced only after the development of transfer pricing rules (assignment of income to/between subsidiaries of multinational companies). In other words--the loophole was deliberately designed to get around U.S. and European transfer pricing rules and make Ireland "competitive" for multinational corporations.
This is wrong.
UK customers buy ads to be shown in the UK to UK viewers, from UK staff at Google's UK offices. They pay in UK pound sterling, from UK bank accounts. So far everything is in the UK. It is only at the very end of the process that someone in Google's Ireland office pushes a button to close the sale, thus taking the sale out of the UK (and our tax system) and into Ireland and their tax system.
This is a transparent dodge to avoid paying tax. It might be legal, but it's sleazy.
> but not any specifics about exactly what those loopholes are.
You don't know what you're talking about, which is fine, but why go to all that effort to create scenarios that aren't happening rather than just asking what is happening?
Except, arguably, the most important thing: the search algorithm and database that brings those UK customers to view those ads in the first place.
In any case, my point isn't that what Google is doing is the right answer. My point is that its quite debatable even from our armchairs how much tax revenue the UK is entitled to from Google's activities in the country. Google is just taking advantage of that complexity.
It's not that debatable - we'll see unified tax codes across the EU. Some companies (not just Google) pushed things too far and set up weird schemes that exist only to reduce tax to a minimum.
> Google is just taking advantage of that complexity.
"Taking advantage of" also has negative connotations. Exploiting.
Nobody is suggesting double taxation, but google does a substantial amount of (profitable) business in the UK, and (at least morally) that portion should be taxed in the UK.
I guess the biggest loophole, even more than the double Irish, is non-existing or very lenient transfer pricing rules...
You can take the most straightforward law and it still won't withstand a company putting all their IP in a tax haven and then attributing most of their revenues to their tax haven subsidiary. That's not taking advantage of a "loophole" that's taking advantage of the fact that: 1) accounting for revenue is inherently complicated, regardless of the tax laws, especially for service businesses and software services businesses at that; and 2) multi-national corporations must have some way to attribute income to the various countries in which they operate; it wouldn't be fair for every country to individually tax all the company's income separately.
It's instructive to try and figure out a tax law that would allow say the U.K. to reach some portion of Google's income. It's harder than it seems. For example, is it relevant that Google has customers in the U.K.? It shouldn't be--there is no sales tax on search services. If someone in the U.K. for example calls up their accountant in the U.S. for advice, as a general rule the accountant isn't liable for income taxes in the U.K. Is it relevant that Google has servers in the U.K.? Sure. But how relevant? How much of the value of Google's service derives from the servers in the U.K. versus the code and algorithms that were developed in California? I think most people would agree that the servers are just incidental--the real value of Google's services is the algorithms and data. So why should the mere existence of servers in the U.K. entitle the country to tax some substantial amount of Google's income?