Did they "shill" for the war? Yes. Was I misled by them? Yes. But in the grander scheme of things that was an excellent experience for me because it showed me to be critical of even my most trusted news sources.
I still have a well read subscription to this day, along with Harvard Business Review.
Right now if you read between the lines The Economist is clearly saying that world wide income taxes are going to start sky rocketing in 3 to 6 years. Plan accordingly. RRSPs or TFSA (Roth IRA or 401k)? Most people will keep at it with their RRSPs and cry their heart out when taxes go up.
Why do you have to read between the lines? Maybe economists don't say things in plain English so they can always deny that they were wrong.
On the other hand, I like economists like Mike Shedlock, who crystal-clearly explains himself (Google his blog). He has been right about the coming deflation for a long time.
Without judgment of your claims about WMD and the Iraq War, I'd recommend that you take a look at the HN guidelines on comments and submissions:
http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
It's pretty hard to have only a lukewarm opinion on these issues, and there's sufficient diversity of views around here to ensure that arguments on political topics are fractious and unenlightening. So we tend to avoid those.
I highly recommend these articles, which describe a similar thought process:
We ignore this at our peril. But overall, you're right. Little is ever gained from political debate, and this probably isn't the place for it.
Restating:
"Don't leap to assume the worst of others".
or
"People can come to different conclusions honestly - disagreeing with you does not mean that they are venal".
or
"Reasonable people can differ".
Is it safe to assume the same of media outlets? My intuition says no. Management sets the tone and the editorial position. Editors and staff execute. That provides ample room for what would be psychotic behavior if management, the editors and staff were all one person.
Disagree entirely.
When evaluating complex choices in a chaotic world, we humans use tons of heuristics. There are a lot of things that aren't quantifiable information, but still allow two rational people to reach different conclusions: models of the universe, weight attached to different speakers, moral stances, worldviews, etc.
At the end of the day, I tend to view argument as vulgar, but put up with it in striving for truth.
Then came Iraq and WMD. WMD was so clearly a cover story, such obvious propaganda. I'd open up the Economist, expecting to read some scalding critique of GWB, and instead find them pushing the same damn line. WTF?
I'd beware of it. The corruptive power of intelligent yet intellectually dishonest argument should not be underestimated.