Re:Ask HN: Does anybody else like the syntax of Algol 60?
by smokeapotamus on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:08PM
(#5764123)
When you look closely, C is a very academic programming language, and its academic influence can be seen in its design-level decisions.
For instance, why does C differentiate between for loops and while loops? Because mathematically there's a natural partition between the two: for loops correspond to primitive recursion, and while loops correspond to total recursion.
Here's another one: why are unions called unions? Because, if types are interpreted as sets, the C union is directly equivalent to the set theoretic union. Similarly, structures are directly equivalent to the Cartesian product (although they are not named appropriately).
K&R were geniuses, not only in practical programming, but in the egg-head understanding of the mathematical theory behind programming languages.
Re:Ask HN: Does anybody else like the syntax of Algol 60?
by inetsee on Friday May 24, 2013 @12:56PM
(#5764042)
Algol was the first programming language I learned in college. I also used Ada professionally for years. I believe that Ada is not at all like Algol, even though Ada was nominally based on the Algol family of languages (including Pascal). I think of Ada as a monster of a language, more like PL/I than Algol, and very difficult to learn in its entirety. Algol is an elegant language, and I think you can learn enough of it to make use of its power in a fraction of the time you'd spend getting proficient with Ada.
Re:Ask HN: Does anybody else like the syntax of Algol 60?
by breadbox on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:09PM
(#5764126)
To be clear, I was talking more about how it was perceived at the time, not about how it actually was. (And of course, what was kitchen-sink-worthy in 1960 would be seen as ultracompact today.) But in any case, I bow to someone with actual experience.
Algol perhaps had the disadvantage of being far more popular among academics than among actual programmers. Perhaps for that reason Algol became the lingua franca of pseudocode, while C became the lingua franca of actual code.
(I don't know if this is fair, but I've always had the impression that Algol was a bit like Ada in its time: respected by those who used it, but a bit too kitchen-sink to be popular among implementors.)