News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First world demons by michaelochurch on Friday May 24, 2013 @09:38AM (#5762620)
Unless that is, you’re in a job you don’t enjoy and the reason you’ve coached yourself not to leave it is that you haven’t found anything “worthy enough” to start yourself.

No, the problem is money. Good ideas are not that rare. "Worthy" ideas are not that rare. The money to implement them is almost impossible to come by, whether you're in a corporation or raising on the outside.

Free-floating capital is not actually that rare. Talent is not that rare, "talent shortage" whinging aside. The problem is a bilateral and cataclysmic distrust between both sides. Money doesn't trust Talent not to steal so it injects a bunch of useless management that makes Talent impossible to unlock. Talent doesn't trust Money not to be stupid and develops a deep, smoldering cynicism that the rest of the world misperceives as obnoxious entitlement.

The problem is that any idiot can raise money for something any idiot can do. On the other hand, if you try to convince someone to pay you, even at the level of mere salary money to do something worthwhile, you get a lot of questions because not everyone can do those useful things. You get: why you? Which is actually a valid question, even if mildly insulting, because things that are worthwhile are hard.

We end up all working for the smooth-talkers selling trivial ideas because they've been overriding the "why you?" objections since college, when it involved booze and women with low self-esteem and, by age 30, they're very practiced at overcoming, for example, "last minute resistance" (LMR). So when they see LMR in investors, they know what to do, and we don't.

Re:First world demons by gizmo on Friday May 24, 2013 @09:52AM (#5762703)
I notice most of your posts lately have a very negative tone. I don't think the negativity is really justified, given how many opportunities there are for programmers. Life isn't just good for programmers, it's also getting better every day. We are probably living in the golden age of internet startups, where small 3 man shops can effectively compete with large enterprises. This won't be true forever, but it's true today.

If you don't have any money (and let's face it, most of us don't), you can still start a startup. You can work on your project in evenings and nights. Or you save money and quit your job for 8 months or so. Or you can work part time on your startup and do part-time contracting work on the side.

Starting a software startup is so much easier than opening a bar or a restaurant or a jeans shop it's not even funny. People put their life savings in ordinary businesses like these every day, and more often than not they get utterly crushed by reality. A restaurant without customers can't afford to keep the doors open for long. Buying a 30k kitchen and hiring 5 people before the first customer has walked through the door is scary. We programmers in contrast can just pivot until we find something people are willing to pay for. We can build half a product and use server analytics to figure out which direction is best. We have unique insights in our users and customers and the press loves to write about anything that involves startups. There are so many things subtly working in our favor!

Doing a startup isn't easy. But nobody is entitled to an easy road to guaranteed riches. But doing a startup is possible even if you're broke, don't have any connections and are only a mediocre programmer or business person.

Of course the VC money game is rigged to an extent. So what. If you have traction you have leverage and if you have leverage you'll still get a good deal. And if you have paying customers you may not even need VC money. These are, in the big scheme of things, not things to get terribly upset about.

Re:First world demons by michaelochurch on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:13AM (#5762857)
I'm probably older than you (almost 30) and I don't think you're aware of the long-term career risks in this industry. Yes, it's cheaper to go all-in on a startup, and you might build something that makes life (yours and others') a lot better. There are a lot of great things about living in 2013. There certainly are opportunities that didn't exist 20 years ago.

However, what happens when your bootstrapped startup fails is an unholy cocktail of the following:

    a. Your savings is depleted. 
    b. You learn a lot, which overqualifies you for junior-level work. 
    c. People try to take advantage of (a) and offer you low-level positions.
Rapid learning (b) and zero credibility advancement (c) is a recipe for disaster, because you'll probably fail when you get shunted into some bullshit low-level job after having been "spoiled" by the experience of getting do real work.

It's the career problems that make this game an unholy mess: the fact that most so-called "tech" jobs are career-killing, subordinate wastes of talent that slowly turn you into an unemployable idiot. It's the risk that you'll be 37 and taking orders from a 25-year-old "tech lead" who only knows half a programming language and won't listen to your ideas. Worst of all, at that age you probably have a spouse and kids, so suicide isn't an ethically defensible option. At that point, you just have to suffer for 40 years and die of natural causes.

Re:First world demons by jdbernard on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:53AM (#5763153)
You are my age, and I intend this to be friendly. Gizmo is right. You have too much potential left to be so negative. This negative view of employment in our industry is not unique to software. The same concerns about getting stuck in a career-killing, life-draining job are found in most professions.

I don't know you personally, so I am hesitant to put words in your mouth or infer what you are feeling. So I'll just talk about myself.

What made the difference for me was attitude. It sounds trite but it's true. Some people are too motivated to let themselves be beaten down by a bad job or a bad boss. They continue to struggle through until they change things for the better. I used to be that kind of person, but I gave up hope. I had to find a way to convince myself that I was smart enough, could work hard enough, and could be persistent enough to force positive change in my life. That I would carve a good path through life with my bare hands if I had to. The other alternative was for that negative view of career option to become a self-fulfilling prophesy.

I have three children myself, the oldest of which is 4 years old. For their sake I cannot kill myself no matter how bad I feel about my prospects. But also for their sake I cannot let myself get beaten back into a hopeless corner where I come home depressed every day about my life. If I come home every day dead already, what hope do they have of seeing the wonder and beauty of life that makes it worth living? Even without the responsibility of kids I have seen too much good in life to ever be convinced that death is preferable.

Re:First world demons by winter_blue on Friday May 24, 2013 @11:57AM (#5763674)
I know I'm breaking HN guidelines, but thanks for that comment. :)
Re:First world demons by gizmo on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:25AM (#5762952)
You're not older than me. And if you believe that a career setback means suicide becomes a rational option... I don't know what to say.

There are so many things in life that can go horribly horribly wrong that the risk of career setback is completely acceptable in pursuit of a dream. Every kid who decides to major in ancient languages, philosophy or creative arts takes a way bigger risk and nobody bats an eye.

Re:First world demons by tptacek on Friday May 24, 2013 @12:54PM (#5764031)
You're a 29 year old software developer. You live in a country full of unemployed tool and die engineers, journeyman construction workers, print journalists, steelworkers, and telephony engineers. Your profession, on the other hand, has the lowest unemployment in the country.

If you feel like suicide is something that enters the equation for anyone in your profession, I'd like to urge you to talk to a psychiatrist.

Re:First world demons by michaelochurch on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:29PM (#5764233)
I'm not worried about now. There are jobs now. I'm worried about the future, because unless you either (a) align a string of high-value projects or (b) move into management, you are toast by a certain age in our industry, no matter how good you are. I know some top-notch programmers who've been utterly screwed. (I'm not in that category, but don't want to end up there in 15 years.)
Re:First world demons by tptacek on Friday May 24, 2013 @02:16PM (#5764463)
Neither of those statements are true. You consistently seem to equate "not in the spotlight" with "screwed"; or, more (or less, depending your POV) charitably, you evince some signs of mental illness (anxiety, depression).

It's not really any of my business, but on the off chance that you haven't talked to a professional about that possibility, I think you might consider doing that. You sound deeply unhappy.

Re:First world demons by tbrownaw on Friday May 24, 2013 @12:27PM (#5763863)
I'm probably older than you (almost 30) and I don't think you're aware of the long-term career risks in this industry.

I'm also almost 30, and am one of the younger people here. Maybe half of the people who were here (on the same team as me) when I started in 2007 are still here, but not all on the same team any more. A couple have been here thru several acquisitions, and long enough to have stories about losing the office we had in the World Trade Center. My direct supervisor has been with the company in various roles (not all IT) longer than I've been alive.

It's the career problems that make this game an unholy mess: the fact that most so-called "tech" jobs are career-killing, subordinate wastes of talent that slowly turn you into an unemployable idiot.

So don't accept that. My job was supposed to be translating "this field goes here" into Informatica (etl tool) mappings; ie code-monkey on a shitty non-textual turing-incomplete proprietary "language". Instead, after learning Informatica and SQL and PL/SQL all while on the job, I started writing things to automate the more repetitive parts. Now most of my time is spent maintaining and improving a set of tools for the rest of the team, which I (re-)wrote in C#, PL/SQL, Java, and the occasional bit of C, Perl, or Unix shell script.

It's the risk that you'll be 37 and taking orders from a 25-year-old "tech lead" who only knows half a programming language and won't listen to your ideas.

That seems a bit exaggerated, but I suppose it could happen if management was all technically clueless and you never bothered to learn anything resembling people-skills.

Worst of all, at that age you probably have a spouse and kids, so suicide isn't an ethically defensible option.

Um... go talk to a psychiatrist? Please?

Re:First world demons by wglb on Friday May 24, 2013 @03:03PM (#5764695)
I have been in leading-edge programming since a good bit before you were born. I have been part of many startups, one very successful, another one on hold, a consulting firm that had a nice exit.

Very much in contrast what you have said in this post and in other posts that you have offered here, I find the demand for seasoned programmers, developers, architects at an all-time high. I have recently had to turn down two very lucrative engagements due to my apparent unclonability.

I have had low spots careerwise--a period of self-unemployment, but I was determined to not get into the negative thinking, as I am sensing in your posts.

My wife bought me a fiction book by Garth Stein, The Art of Racing in the Rain. One of the phrases in the book was "Your car goes where your eyes are." If your eyes are on the wall next to the race track, that is where the car will go.

To put it in non-racing terms, you are likely to fulfill your expectations.

Re:First world demons by BashiBazouk on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:21PM (#5764194)
I had a bunch of friends who worked at the local movie theater when I was in my early 20's. There was this little old guy who took tickets at the door. He was in his late 70's or early 80's. I think most people would look at him and think pity, he didn't have a good enough retirement that he had to take a low end job to make ends meet. Far from the truth. He ran a significant portion of the red cross in the middle east for many years. One of his more interesting stories was he and his wife's car broke down in the Jordan desert. The King's motorcade drove by and stopped. He and his wife had tea with the king and queen in the limo while his men fixed the car. He had a fine retirement but his wife had died and he just needed something to do to feel alive. The guy dined with kings and actually did save the world, at least as much as the world can be saved, and in the end a low paying dead end job was perfectly fine for his happiness. You define your state of mind, not how well your job one ups your peers or the number of zeros on your paycheck...
Re:First world demons by msabalau on Friday May 24, 2013 @02:36PM (#5764560)
Of course, one could have been T.S. Eliot, with a reasonable case to be made that you were the greatest poet of the 20th century, and find yourself working in a sub-basement of a bank for eight years to support yourself while pursuing your true vocation.

"So one must find out how to become happy oneself. Wanting to transform the world without discovering one's true self is like trying to cover the whole world with leather to avoid the pain of walking on stones and thorns. It is much simpler to wear shoes."

- Ramana Maharshi

Re:First world demons by michaelochurch on Friday May 24, 2013 @04:15PM (#5764981)
You make a strong point. Yet there's one crucial difference.

In Eliot's time, people didn't have access to a full time series of your professional social status. I'm sure that it sucked for him to work in a bank basement for 8 years, but he never worried that someone would find that out on LinkedIn and he'd be in the basement permanently.

There was a time in which it was much more OK to do low-level work, if only because you could pull a Don Draper and reinvent yourself with a different history.

Re:First world demons by Swizec on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:25AM (#5762953)
Wow, bitter much?

You don't have to take a low-level job. You don't have to stay at a low-level job. I have noticed people are willing to pay you much more for interesting work than they are for boring work. Just price yourself high enough and the interesting work will start coming.

Re:First world demons by ebiester on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:06PM (#5764110)
In this world? No.

(I am older than you by a little bit.) This is what you do:

D. Take a contract with a fortune 1000, spend a year digging yourself out of a hole, and move on.

Does it mean that somewhere early along your path, you need to pick up some Java or .Net or Oracle? Sure. But you have decades of productive coding ahead of you; a few years is not going to kill your dreams.

Look: not every portion of your life is going to be glamorous, save for the very lucky. It is possible to learn something from everybody, even a "25-year-old who only knows half a programming language."

I think what I learned most from spending some time in the developed world is not to be so self-righteous about bullshit like this. You could be parking your ass in front of a subway line telling people, "God Bless you, please buy a packet of Kleenex."

Re:First world demons by snowwrestler on Friday May 24, 2013 @04:13PM (#5764967)
I'm 37 with a family and I care a lot less about this stuff than I did when I was 25. I just feel very differently about my career now than I did 12 years ago.

Am I changing the world, blowing everyone's mind? No. I'm doing work that's pretty fun, working with people I like, and hanging with my family on the weekend.

Happiness is a process not a result. If you want to focus on some perceived injustice in your past, that is of course your right, but let's not pretend it's a universal human condition.

I mean, let's take your worst-case scenario. Broadly speaking, most jobs in the world are substantially worse than a low-level computer programming job.

Re:First world demons by count on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:29AM (#5762977)
Or you could grow up and leave the Valley, and realize the world is a lot larger than you seem to appreciate.

Or just kill yourself now, and save us all the whining.

Re:First world demons by wglb on Friday May 24, 2013 @03:13PM (#5764733)
Inappropriate.
Re:First world demons by winter_blue on Friday May 24, 2013 @11:48AM (#5763574)
> I notice most of your posts lately have a very negative tone.

No offense intended to michaelochurch; but a Greasemonkey script or something that auto-hides or flags comments from selected users (that you pick / configure), would come in really handy.[1]

It would make a HN much more happier and cheerful place.

[1] EDIT: An afterthought: a database where people could share their "flagged users" would be a useful addition. One could then easily figure out who the "most flagged users" were (for negativity, rashness/harshness/pick-your-gripe), and then add an option were you could also hide comments by the "top flagged" users in this database.

Re:First world demons by intellection on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:30AM (#5762984)
Pain is marginalized by people upset with pathos.

Repeating reality is (is lost..) that programming has a real life cost equally important to every type of pain. Whether counting greater, technical, systemic, organizational and or proprietary pains, sometimes our lives are counted by asking people to pay with pain.

Framed negative and or positive, equally real, paying programming and paying with programming et al, still has real life opportunity cost and real life opportunity lost.

Re:First world demons by FD3SA on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:26AM (#5762955)
"We end up all working for the smooth-talkers selling trivial ideas because they've been overriding the "why you?" objections since college..."

This is a very interesting take on the issue, and not one I see discussed often on HN. The reality is that evolutionary psychology is the ultimate motive force in all human societies. The power imbalances in the work world that you have so thoroughly elucidated in your writings is but a mere symptom of the most basic evolutionary impulse: extract dominance from all.

Why do pointy haired bosses exist? Why do smooth-talkers like Steve Jobs always get the glory over technocrats like Steve Wozniak? Why do people so willingly submit to injustice? Weakness. People submit to those who they fear are powerful enough to harm them. Most often, even a weak bluff vaguely threatening future harm is enough to extract complete submission. The root of this is based on the evolutionary psychology of mammal behavior. Mammals exert dominance by challenging their peers: submit to me or pay the price. In the context of artisans (Technocrats), we can go back to the Feudal era, where artisans and farmers owed their lives to the Feudal lords, and could lose it any instant by not submitting some or all of their surplus value created when commanded to do so. Although the artisans created all the value in society, the lords were free to help themselves to it at will, because they were the ones who were willing to use force if their demands were not met. Although this strategy comes with risk, the rewards are disproportionately high, which is why history follows the story of one conqueror after another.

The only way artisans can gain control of their lives is if they beat the Feudal lords at their own game, ruthlessly and without mercy. This means playing as dirty as necessary to win, but still keeping your ideals intact. That is the true challenge of the Technocrat: defeat the Psychopaths using their own tools without becoming one of them. But make no mistake, they won’t go down easy. Look at Julian Assange, Noam Chomsky, and countless others who know this and have tried, in vain, to change the status quo. The choice is simple: submit to the psychopaths and live in their world, or risk everything and attempt to change the dynamic to your favor.

P.S. You made references to psychopaths and their success with females. This is well documented, and I would recommend reading about the Dark Triad personality traits.

Re:First world demons by guylhem on Friday May 24, 2013 @12:49PM (#5764001)
Excellent analysis. Weakness is the reason why some posturing fools can extract surplus from productive workers.

Various answers have been proposed by different philosophy - from a worker revolution which michaelochurch seems to support (correct me if I'm wrong), ala Marx, to just refusing to submit and do your own thing aside, ala Atlas Shrugged.

I for one would prefer this last option, but that's just my opinion. Ayn Randt wrote nothing new - she just wrote it better than La Boetie did in 1553 - almost 500 years ago: :

To him, the great mystery of politics was obedience to rulers. Why in the world do people agree to be looted and otherwise oppressed by government overlords? It is not just fear, Boetie explains in “The Discourse on Voluntary Servitude,” for our consent is required. And that consent can be non-violently withdrawn.

The most important is to have at least a bit of stoicism, because behind weakness is fear - the fear to lose something.

Weakness is the reason, but fear is the cause.

Give up your fears, accept the possibility of loss in advance, every morning, and weakness will vanish.

Re:First world demons by _pmf_ on Friday May 24, 2013 @12:33PM (#5763894)
> Why do people so willingly submit to injustice? Weakness. People submit to those who they fear are powerful enough to harm them.

That's bullshit. Let's take the late Steve Jobs. While his psychopathic tendencies have probably evoked fear within Apple, it does not explain his influence on the general public outside of Apple.

Re:First world demons by saraid216 on Friday May 24, 2013 @12:43PM (#5763954)
Fun fact: Outside Apple, there were plenty of people who criticized Jobs.
Re:First world demons by Androsynth on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:30PM (#5764239)
greed, envy and a celebrity worshiping culture
Re:First world demons by lifeisstillgood on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:14AM (#5762865)
> We end up all working for the smooth-talkers selling > trivial ideas because they've been overriding the "why > you?" objections since college, when it involved booze and > women with low self-esteem and, by age 30, they're very > practiced at overcoming, for example, "last minute > resistance" (LMR). So when they see LMR in investors, they > know what to do, and we don't.

Fantastic.

Re:First world demons by michaelochurch on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:16AM (#5762887)
If I didn't have a clinical/diagnosed level of mysophobia (in my case, moral mysophobia) I would seriously do the sociopath thing just to express my contempt for the species.

My problem is that I am forced at a neurological level to be ethical and honest. In a world full of (and run by) liars, it really sucks.

Re:First world demons by angersock on Friday May 24, 2013 @10:58AM (#5763181)
Shoot me an email--let's chat. You seem kind of ragey.