News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by pg on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:38PM (#5759988)
This would be accurate if time were going backwards. The world it describes is how things were in the 90s.

For the last two decades, at least, the power of hackers/makers relative to MBAs/smooth talkers has consistently increased, and that trend shows no sign of slowing down.

Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by eldavido on Thursday May 23, 2013 @07:54PM (#5760338)
Forget the hacker/maker vs. "business guy" distinction. The article's central claim is the rise of a kind of person adept at playing the political game of VC -- raising a round, and then getting soft-acquihired if their company fails.

I, for one, have a hard time believing that every startup M&A transaction adds shareholder value to the acquirer. A more likely narrative, and one the author of the article calls into question, is that the entrepreneur has friends/other back-channels at the acquirer and uses these personal connection to engineer the "acquisition" of their company, at the expense of shareholders.

Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by pg on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:05AM (#5761353)
I can't say for sure this never happens, but I've never seen an instance of it. A startup is composed of its people. For an acquiring company to take on people they didn't want would be the ultimate sacrifice.
Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by amarghose on Thursday May 23, 2013 @07:19PM (#5760194)
> hackers/makers relative to MBAs/smooth talkers

I think the article is more referring to Hackers/Makers that are also smooth talkers. Obviously an MBA/Business guy with no technical experience/knowledge is not going to be able to pull off any sort of political entrepreneurship in VC-istan.

Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by tptacek on Thursday May 23, 2013 @07:29PM (#5760241)
I stopped trying to parse this comment just before it gave me an aneurysm as I tried to resolve what "VC-istan" might refer to and how non-tech MBAs had no influence there. VC's fund tons of companies headed by operators with no technical experience (look at some 2012 portfolios to see this). It is eas-ier to get external funding if you're a tech with no company operating experience, but it still not eas-y to do that. So it's probably not "obvious" that MBA/business types have no influence wherever "VC-istan" is. Which is I think a good reason not to start calling it "VC-istan".
Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by MisterWebz on Thursday May 23, 2013 @10:07PM (#5760850)
The word "VC-istan" has been used a lot in this thread and even elsewhere, I don't understand why you put so much emphasis on not understanding what it means.
Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by tptacek on Thursday May 23, 2013 @10:44PM (#5760984)
For example: because the commenter upthread doesn't appear to know what it means, since they think that MBAs have no influence there. Because it doesn't mean anything; it's a slippery term, meant to diffract understanding rather than focus it.
Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by nostrademons on Thursday May 23, 2013 @07:28PM (#5760233)
A hacker/maker who is also a smooth talker is always going to do better than one who isn't a smooth talker, though. That's like saying "A person who builds useful stuff but also has an Ivy-League degree will be hired over someone who builds useful stuff but doesn't." Duh, but it doesn't mean that building useful stuff is less useful than having the Ivy-League degree (or being a smooth talker).
Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by wilfra on Thursday May 23, 2013 @09:40PM (#5760755)
One must not be an MBA/smooth talker to be neck-deep in SV politics. Here are some companies he was probably referring to (or would be if he studied them closely): Path, Color Labs, Quora, Asana, Airtime and Foursquare.

I'd cry if two of those services went away but I'd be lying if I didn't acknowledge they are cogs in the machine this article was describing.

TechCrunch is the elephant in the room. Basically any startup that is successful at getting frequent TC coverage could be accused of playing the politics game. However whether they are using TC to reinforce their safety net or using it grow their company (or both) is open to interpretation.

Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by pg on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:01AM (#5761346)
Back in the 90s, most of those would have been among the more earnest, nerdy startups being funded.
Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by reaclmbs on Sunday May 26, 2013 @03:26PM (#5772123)
> Basically any startup that is successful at getting frequent TC coverage could be accused of playing the politics game

WTF are you talking about? Getting into techcrunch is as simple as writing a check to a PR firm.

Re:The terrifying rise of the political entrepreneur by ucee054 on Friday May 24, 2013 @07:08AM (#5762114)
Yes but it's nowhere near good enough and only improving slowly.