News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by 3pt14159 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:35AM (#5757396)
No they will not.

The amount of effort required to shrink real knowledge worker jobs is astronomical compared to simply driving a car. After the singularity, fine. But even that will require a massive, massive amount of work. The low hanging fruit for increasing knowledge work output is in Gattaca not AI.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by kybernetyk on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:40AM (#5757432)
I guess the point where an AI can replace a programmer is the point where a technological singularity begins. Because at that point the AI is capable of improving its own code which would lead to a 'runaway reaction'.

And if you're in a post-singularity world you don't really have to worry about jobs anymore. So I guess being a programmer is pretty future proof ;)

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by lpvn on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:10PM (#5757621)
The fact that automation will take most of population out of work doesn't necessarily mean that your job will be completely automated. Look at a manufacturing plant for instance, human workers are still necessary but you need 10x less workers and they'll produce 10x more than 50 years ago.

The same holds for technical areas, we can't say for sure when we'll have strong AI but in the meantime we're gonna need less and less people to do the job that a lot of people do today. This all to say that the problem of unemployment isn't about every single person in the world being unable to get a job, if you have 35% of your population unable to exchange their labour capacities for a living then this is a huge social problem.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by nostromo on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:59AM (#5757566)
Software is already replacing programmers through gains in efficiency if not AI.

Just look at what a small number of programmers can accomplish today vs 10 or 20 years ago.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by danielweber on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:13PM (#5757645)
There's not a finite amount of software that the world needs, though. We're standing on the shoulders of giants but the top of the ladder is not even in sight.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by ippisl on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:15PM (#5757657)
It depends i think. Let's say you develop mobile games for a living and then the unemployment rate rises to 20-30%. The economy collapses, and nobody buys games. Not the best place to be while paying the mortgage.

Ironically , if you're a programer who increases productivity, i.e. causes unemployment, you save money. In sour economy the need to save money is the greatest.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by conroe64 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:28PM (#5757725)
So, post singularity, people with no wealth or ability to work will be prevented from starving? There are many people that are dying from starvation today. Why would this change?
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by rtkwe on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:05PM (#5757962)
The idea of the singularity also includes post-scarcity for at least basic survival needs. The logic being when robots & AIs take over all the jobs we can increase the output to a point where goods are exceedingly abundant. Granted that path involves quite a bit of faith that there's some reason to provide, but it's not terribly unreasonable if a bit idealistic.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by conroe64 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:55PM (#5758306)
This idea fails because we had the resources to feed everybody today yet it doesn't happen. In the future, when techno-baron A sees that techno-baron B is getting ahead, techno-baron A consumes more resources in order to defeat techno-baron B. If people are in the way of that, and they are of no use to any techno-barons they are pushed aside.

There was "post-scarcity for basic survival needs" for millions of years already. When life first formed on earth, there was food enough for every organism. That didn't prevent organisms from fighting each other.

Competition and the extinction of the losers has been a central theme of life since it began. Being at the top of the food pyramid, and in a first-world country has made us forget that fact. The idea that humanity can rise above this, formed from living in this social-economic bubble for far too long, is just hubris.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by rtkwe on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:16PM (#5758450)
Things have always been this way isn't really strong argument for this. There are many ways we could set up a society in which the basic needs for everyone's survival is needed and the surplus is allocated in a way which most benefits society. A perfectly impartial central planning AI comes to mind.

That's where the big difference comes from your example of '"post-scarcity for basic survival needs" for millions of years already.' there's never been the coordination and impartiality to distribute and coordinate at that level.

As for today if we coordinated and there were no economic considerations we could feed everyone today. It's just that there's not the planning or monetary forces in place to make it happen.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by conroe64 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:49PM (#5758660)
A central planning AI to impose fairness and the right to basic survival could only come about and remain standing if there was enough support for it from those already in power to allow this. How would you suppose this would come about?

The future will hold a very different scenario than a typical first-world country today where the populous actually produces useful work. As a leader, instead you have a population who who in-fight amongst themselves for the best of the consumable goods and produce absolutely nothing of value for you. To make matters worse, they continually attempt to push their boundaries, growing bigger and bigger if not thwarted (as life normally does).

My other point, that techno-baron A will want to fight/defend himself against techno-baron B still applies. Won't anything that techno-baron A needs to do to defend himself against techno-baron B trump the humanitarian concerns for maintaining the lifestyle of his subjects that give absolutely nothing back to him?

Even if techno-baron A is morally inclined to do so, there will be others that are more brutal and would not. And even if the moral techo-baron A is able to completely conquer the world (seems very unlikely considering how schizophrenically both brutal and compassionate he would have to be), then his hold on it will at some time cease, probably under duress from threat(s) within.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by rtkwe on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:00PM (#5759796)
People have been trying to fairly distribute resources to give everyone a basic standard living for ages. It's the basic idea behind welfare, socialism, and communism, there's a precedent for trying to do exactly what I described as the CPAI.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by conroe64 on Friday May 24, 2013 @12:03AM (#5761223)
So why do you think that an AI could do any better? You really think it's too complicated for people to figure out how distribute wealth fairly enough and that's why it failed? All an AI tasked with making things fair for everybody can do is create a plan. It cannot execute it, it cannot enforce it.

Why would people follow it? Why would some rich and powerful guy with connections forgo all his power to some CPAI that was set up? How would he maintain his ego when the world no longer shakes from his every footstep? How would he repay all the favors he made to those that got him there?

AI is just a tool, like the gun, the ship or the railroad. It's not some panacea that is going to protect human nature from itself.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by rtkwe on Friday May 24, 2013 @04:07PM (#5764939)
I think one of the reason it failed in the past was a mixture of corruption and incomplete technology. There just wasn't the tech in place for things to be efficiently planned accurately and efficiently.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by kybernetyk on Thursday May 23, 2013 @04:05PM (#5759187)
> This idea fails because we had the resources to feed everybody today yet it doesn't happen.

The idea is that in a post singularity[1] world we won't be making those decisions. A hopefully wise AI will manage and decide everything for us. (Even if we wouldn't want it to.)

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_singularity

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by kybernetyk on Thursday May 23, 2013 @04:02PM (#5759166)
> The logic being when robots & AIs take over all the jobs we can increase the output to a point where goods are exceedingly abundant.

That or the AI decides to exterminate us. In both cases jobs won't be a major concern.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by rtkwe on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:48PM (#5760045)
Yeah that's always an option for how this could go. I prefer to be positive cause if a post-singularity AI wants to kill me there's not much I can do.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by simonbrown on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:21PM (#5758035)
What if natural resources are scarce?
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by rtkwe on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:05PM (#5758376)
Basic living is perfectly sustainable for our current population and beyond I think (and I think I've read but have no source), anything above that could be allotted based on the newly scarce resource of human creativity or whatever we decide. Also many scarce resources could likely be made non scarce with 'free' labor of robots/AIs.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by JulianMorrison on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:12PM (#5757638)
You don't have to fully automate a job. You just have to replace most of the human labour. The "secretary" sector wasn't obliterated by word processing and email, but it was crushed down to a vestigial remnant. The "lawyer" sector could be as easily crushed by Watson.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by ujeezy on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:10PM (#5758403)
> You don't have to fully automate a job

Right, and a lot of today's technology bridges the gap by shifting work to the end user. How often does anyone call a travel agent anymore?

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by wvenable on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:16PM (#5757662)
It's already happening. The number of "knowledge worker" jobs is shrinking. The low-skilled are the first to go and software is replacing them, just as low-skilled labor jobs have been replaced by machines.

It's a slow process, as the quantity and depth of software increases, the number of knowledge workers decreases. That's literally the reason for existence for most software.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by 3pt14159 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:54PM (#5758292)
Low-skill and knowledge worker are at the opposite ends of the spectrum.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by wvenable on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:25PM (#5759931)
In this case, Low skill is adjective on knowledge worker not a category unto itself.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by Sven7 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:48PM (#5757859)
You don't need AI to see the number of programmers required on a project to exponentially shrink.

Five years ago to build a simple video chat you needed a team of hardcore programmers with expertise in video, audio, networking, real time protocols and telecom. Today it takes a couple of lines of javascript through WebRTC.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by greenyoda on Friday May 24, 2013 @11:04PM (#5766210)
But aren't users demanding more and more features from software as time goes on, and won't this added size and complexity create additional work for programmers even though the stuff we did in the previous release is now easier to do? For example, compare the amount of software that went into a phone ten years ago with the gigabytes of software that sits on a smartphone today, or the complexity of the UI on a phone ten years ago vs. today. Not to mention the increased functionality of the servers at the back-ends of all these apps.

Also, if you're starting a project from scratch, you can use the latest and most streamlined technology. But if you're supporting a large code base (millions of lines of code) and adding features to it, you can't just suddenly re-write all your code to use the latest techniques. Also, you may be locked into a technology by your customers. For example, in the enterprise software space, lots of customers have a huge investment in Java application servers on which all their software runs, and if you want to compete in that space, it's easier to sell them a Java-based system than it is to convince them to install and learn to support a Ruby-based system just to run your product. And there's probably much more code (and programmers) in enterprise software -- think of all the software that supports banks, insurance companies, hospitals, government agencies, pharmaceutical companies, etc. -- than in the start-up world. I don't think AI is going to make a dent in that huge, complex pile of legacy software any time soon.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by Sven7 on Saturday May 25, 2013 @05:38PM (#5768960)
Look at state govt employees in the US. A major portion of this labor force is involved in managing data. Even if you take just the "knowledge workers", the number still would be in the hundreds of thousands range. Not counting outsourcing.

Facebook manages the data of 1 billion people, spanning some 200 countries with 5000 employees. No great AI involved.

Glad you bought up enterprise, most of those programmers now come from Indian IT companies. The only sector still employing american programmers is defence. Now if you are right and all those hospitals, pharma companies, insurance companies, banks etc require more and more features to be built for their customers then why do we see this

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/its-time-to-move-on-as-tec...

Why do we see Infosys tanking after almost a decade of being a darling of the stock market.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-05-22/infosys-investors-b...

Of course its all not happening overnight, there are some legacy systems that are still too expensive to replace but it is happening.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by aespinoza on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:47AM (#5757480)
Sadly, I couldn't read the article due to the paywall. But I agree with you. I don't think AI will replace knowledge workers. A couple of decades ago, people used to say that workers in factories would disappear as well. That never happened, at least not completely.

The costs are always a problem. If AI will ever really replace us, is still a mystery for the future. Because for it to work, it would have to be cost effective.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by w1ntermute on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:51AM (#5757509)
> Sadly, I couldn't read the article due to the paywall.

Just open it in Incognito Mode. The Economist uses a simple, cookie-based porous paywall.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by aespinoza on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:59AM (#5757569)
Thanks for the tip. It worked.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by enraged_camel on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:13PM (#5757641)
>>A couple of decades ago, people used to say that workers in factories would disappear as well. That never happened, at least not completely.

It hasn't happened completely, but that is only a matter of time. Manufacturing jobs have been declining at a sharp and steady rate in the US. One part of this may be due to outsourcing, but the other part is due to automation. When machines can do most of the labor, eventually you will only need a few high-level engineers to calibrate those machines.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by ujeezy on Thursday May 23, 2013 @03:01PM (#5758738)
Jobs in U.S. factories disappeared to Asia. Now that offshore manufacturing costs are rising, we can expect more companies to follow Foxconn's example, and invest heavily in machines.

If a job is offshored (as much knowledge work has been), it's a good bet that the next step will be to automate it.

Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by johntb86 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:19PM (#5758027)
It's already started: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405270230337920457747... Lawyers are being replaced by computers for doing pretrial document review. Currently only low-skill low-creativity jobs are being replaced, but that will expand over time.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by msutherl on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:48AM (#5757488)
Gattaca, and computer assisted knowledge work. Let's use humans for what humans are good at and computers for what computers are good at. Let's also work on the interface between those two systems.
Re:Brain work may be going the way of manual work by return0 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:15PM (#5757659)
I would rather prepare for it rather than shove my head in the sand. Is there reason to believe it will come later rather than sooner?